00:00
Hey there, history lovers! August 1840, the Texas coast.
00:04
The quiet town of Linville spots a dust cloud on the horizon and inside it are up to a thousand Comanche riders led by Buffalo Hump, coming to settle the score for a peace talk gone wrong in San Antonio. The locals run for boats and watch their town burn from the bay. Worst Monday ever. Big thanks to our listener James PD for suggesting this topic, and the Comanche are just the start. Tonight we meet five great nations, the Iroquois, the Sioux, the Navajo, the Apache and the Comanche, and we follow how they rose, fought and survived. Hit like and drop a comment.
00:36
Where are you watching from?
00:38
To understand how these five nations ended up steering the fate of a whole continent, we have to rewind the tape. Way back.
00:46
Long before Texas had a coastline worth raiding, long before anyone in Europe had heard the word America, and long before the first horse in our story had even been born, we are heading to the tail end of the last ice age, when a huge part of North America sat under sheets of ice more than a kilometre thick. not exactly prime real estate, and good luck finding a cosy cabin with a fireplace anywhere north of what is now Chicago.
01:10
During this frosty era, so much of the planet's water was locked up in glaciers that sea levels dropped by more than 100 metres. When the ocean pulled back, it exposed a wide bridge of dry land connecting Siberia and Alaska. Scientists call it Beringia. Now, if you're picturing a skinny little path across a frozen strait, with people walking in single file and trying not to slip, let go of that image. Beringia was enormous. In places it stretched around a thousand kilometres from north to south, which makes it less of a bridge and more of a lost subcontinent.
01:43
It was a cold, dry, windswept grassland that researchers sometimes call the Mammoth Steppe. and the name tells you exactly who the main residents were – woolly mammoths, steppe bison, wild horses, caribou, musk oxen, and a few predators that would have been very happy to meet a human for dinner, in the least romantic sense of the word. People lived there too. Genetic studies suggest that a population of hunters may have stayed in or near Beringia for thousands of years, cut off from their relatives in Asia by the harsh climate and blocked from the south by walls of ice.
02:17
Scientists have a fittingly patient name for this idea, the Beringian standstill. Picture the longest layover in human history, with no airport lounge, no snacks and a waiting area that was mostly frozen grass.
02:29
Eventually, more than 15,000 years ago, groups of these people began moving south into the rest of the Americas. How exactly they did it is still one of the great debates in archaeology. For a long time, the favourite theory was an ice-free corridor, a gap that opened between two massive ice sheets on the eastern side of the Rocky Mountains. The problem is that this corridor seems to have become liveable rather late, maybe around 13,000 to 14,000 years ago, and evidence suggests people were already far to the south before that.
02:59
So many researchers now prefer a second route along the Pacific coast. In this scenario, early travellers moved by boat or along the shoreline, living on fish, shellfish, seals and seabirds. Some scientists like to call it the kelp highway because the coast was lined with rich underwater forests of seaweed that supported a buffet of marine life. In other words, the first Americans may have arrived on a seafood diet, which is honestly more sophisticated than most road trips today. The evidence keeps pushing the clock back.
03:30
At a site called Monteverde in southern Chile, archaeologists found traces of a camp dated to about 14,500 years ago, complete with wooden structures, tools and remains of plants and even seaweed. That is the far end of South America. If people were already there, they must have entered the Americas earlier or travelled remarkably fast.
03:51
In Oregon, at the Paisley Caves, researchers discovered something even less glamorous. Fossilised human droppings dated to roughly 14,000 years ago preserved in the dry cave floor. It is not the treasure anyone dreams of finding, but archaeology rarely asks for your preferences. Those little deposits contained human DNA and gave solid proof that people were in the region before the famous culture we're about to meet. And at White Sands in New Mexico, a set of human footprints has been dated by some studies to more than 20,000 years ago.
04:22
That claim is still argued over at conferences, sometimes with an intensity normally reserved for sports fans, but it shows how open the question remains. Which brings us to the Clovis culture. In the early 1930s at a place called Blackwater Draw near the town of Clovis, New Mexico, researchers found finely made stone spear points lying among the bones of mammoths.
04:44
The points had a distinctive look, long and leaf-shaped, with a groove called a flute chipped out from the base so they could be fitted neatly onto a spear shaft.
04:54
Similar points soon turned up from Montana to Florida and from the Great Plains to the Atlantic coast.
05:00
They date to around 13,000 years ago, and for decades they were treated as the signature of the very first Americans. The idea even had a name, Clovis First, and some archaeologists defended it with the stubbornness of a cat refusing to leave a warm laptop. Each time someone suggested an older sight, the reaction was usually polite scepticism, followed by less polite scepticism.
05:22
Over time, sites like Monteverde and the Paisley Caves cracked that consensus. Today Clovis is seen not as the first chapter, but as a remarkably successful and widespread technology that spread quickly across a continent already home to scattered communities. The Clovis toolmakers lived in a world of giants. Mammoths and mastodons, giant ground sloths that could stand taller than an elephant on their hind legs. Enormous armadillo relatives the size of a small car, saber-toothed cats, and the short-faced bear, which could reach well over three metres when standing upright.
05:55
There was even a giant beaver, roughly the size of a modern black bear. Fortunately for the fur traders who will appear later in our story, the modern beaver is a much more manageable, hat-friendly size, and here is a detail worth tucking away for later. North America was also home to native horses. In fact, the horse family evolved on this continent over millions of years. But around 12,000 to 11,000 years ago, horses vanished from the Americas, along with most of the other big animals.
06:24
Scientists still debate whether the main cause was a changing climate, pressure from human hunters or a mix of both.
06:31
Whatever the reason, the continent lost its horses for more than 10,000 years. When they finally came back they arrived on Spanish ships and their return would turn the whole map upside down. We will get there soon.
06:44
After the Age of Giants ended, the people of North America did something that humans do best. They adapted. Over the following thousands of years, which archaeologists call the Archaic Period, communities learned to make the most of very different environments. On the coast they fished. In the forest they hunted deer, gathered nuts and tracked the seasons.
07:05
In the deserts, they became experts on every seed and root worth eating. On the plains, they hunted bison, which had survived the extinction in a smaller form.
07:14
Over time, some groups began to plant crops. Squash and sunflowers were domesticated in eastern North America, and later corn arrived from Mexico, where it had been bred from a wild grass that originally looked nothing like the cob on your plate.
07:28
early corn ears were barely the size of your thumb, which makes the history of agriculture look a lot like a very slow cooking show.
07:35
All this time, languages were changing and splitting as well. By the time Europeans arrived, the area north of Mexico was home to somewhere around 300 languages, grouped into dozens of separate language families. For comparison, almost all of Europe gets by with just a handful of families, and most of its languages belong to only one of them. So when Christopher Columbus called everyone he met Indians, he was not only wrong about geography, he also managed to lump together a range of peoples more diverse than the whole of Europe. Not his finest moment as a navigator, and not a great moment for labelling either.
08:10
That diversity matters for our story, because the five nations in this video are not one people with five different hats. They represent four completely different language families. Their languages are as unrelated to each other as English is to Arabic, Chinese or Finnish. Each of them has its own deep roots, its own long journey and its own point of entry into the history we usually read about.
08:32
Let's begin in the northeast. The Iroquois, or as they call themselves, the Haudenosaunee, speak Iroquoian languages.
08:40
Mohawk, Oneida, Onondaga, Cayuga, Seneca, and Tuscarora all belonged to this family. So did the languages of several of their neighbours and sometimes rivals, including the Wendat, whom the French called the Huron, as well as the Eyrie and the Susquehannock, and far to the south, in the mountains of the Appalachians, lived another Iroquoian-speaking people, the Cherokee.
09:04
Linguists believe the Cherokee branch split off from the northern languages thousands of years ago so a Mohawk speaker and a Cherokee speaker in the 1700s would have understood each other about as well as a modern English speaker understands Old Icelandic. Distant relatives, not chatty cousins. Where did the northern Iroquois come from? For a long time, scholars argued that they had migrated into New York from somewhere farther south. Today, many archaeologists favour a different view, that they developed more or less in place around the Great Lakes and the valleys of New York and southern Ontario.
09:36
Here, the archaeological record shows something important.
09:39
Around the year 900-1300, a culture known as Owasco appears in what is now upstate New York.
09:46
Wasco communities grew corn, lived in villages and built long rectangular houses made of wooden poles and bark. Over the centuries those villages became larger and the houses got longer. Many villages were surrounded by wooden palisades, which tells us that relations between neighbours were not always friendly.
10:04
The key point is that the Iroquois story is rooted in farming. These were people of fields, villages and settled communities long before Europeans showed up. Keep that in mind because their politics, their family structure and their famous confederacy all grew out of that settled farming world.
10:20
Now let's move west to the second family on our map. The Sioux belong to the Siouxan language family, which is far bigger than most people imagine. Alongside the Dakota, Lakota and Nakota, it includes the Crow of Montana, the Hidatsa and Mandan of the Upper Missouri River, the Osage, the Omaha, the Ponca, the Kansa, whose name lives on in the state of Kansas, the Kwapor of Arkansas and the Ho-Chunk of Wisconsin.
10:45
There were even Siouxan speakers as far east as the Carolinas, such as the Catawba. That widespread tells linguists that Siouxan peoples were on the move over a long period of time, branching out in different directions.
10:56
The ancestors of the Sioux lived in the woodlands and lake country of the Upper Mississippi River. Some scholars think the deeper roots of the whole Siouxan family may lie farther east. in the Ohio River Valley, but for the Dakota, Lakota and Nakota themselves, the important homeland is the land of forests, lakes and rivers in what is now Minnesota and Wisconsin. And this is where we have to gently break one of the most popular images in American history. When most people hear the word Sioux, they picture a rider in a feathered war bonnet racing across an endless grassland after a herd of bison That image is real, but it is relatively late.
11:33
For most of their history, the ancestors of the Sioux were forest people. They travelled by canoe, gathered wild plants, hunted deer and lived among lakes rather than on the open plains. The famous horseback Sioux of the movies are a later chapter and how they got there is a story we will follow in detail.
11:52
Our third language family takes us on the longest journey of all. The Navajo and the Apache speak southern Athabascan languages. To understand how strange that is on a map, imagine discovering that a village in southern Italy speaks a language closely related to something spoken only in Norway.
12:08
The Athabascan family is centered far to the north. Most of its languages are spoken in the interior of Alaska and in Western Canada, among peoples such as the Guichin, the Tlisho, and the Dinsulin.
12:21
There are even small Athabascan outposts along the Pacific coast, like the Hoopa in Northern California. And then, thousands of kilometers to the south, in the deserts and mountains of Arizona and New Mexico, there are the Navajo and the Apache.
12:36
The linguistic connection is so clear that even everyday words can give it away. The Navajo call themselves din, which means the people.
12:45
Many northern Athabascan groups use a very similar word, din, with the same meaning. It is a bit like two branches of a family who have not seen each other in 700 years and still say grace the same way.
12:57
linguists have concluded that the ancestors of the navajo and apache came from the north and migrated an enormous distance south probably arriving in the southwest sometime between about 1300 and 1500 that makes them in the long view of north american history relative newcomers to the region They arrived after the great age of the ancestral Pueblan towns we are about to visit, and only a century or two before the Spanish. How exactly they made that journey is still argued over. Some researchers think they travelled along the western edge of the Great Plains, following bison herds.
13:31
Others suggest they moved through the valleys and foothills of the Rocky Mountains. The trouble is that a small mobile population that travels light does not leave much behind for archaeologists. No great stone ruins, no giant mounds, just scattered campsites, a few tools and some pottery that is hard to tell apart from everyone else's.
13:51
These people were very good at moving, which is great for survival and terrible for anyone trying to write their history a thousand years later. There is an even more surprising twist. In 2008, the linguist Edward Vida presented evidence that the Athabascan family, along with its broader relatives known as Nadine, may be distantly connected to the Ket language of central Siberia.
14:13
Ket is spoken today by only a handful of elderly people along the Yenisee River. If the idea is right, it would be the first widely discussed language link between Asia and the Americas, a family reunion across the Bering Strait after many thousands of years.
14:27
Not every linguist is convinced, and the debate continues, but it is a striking reminder that the story we began in Beringia never really disappeared. It is still there, quietly hidden in grammar and vocabulary. And finally, our fourth language family, which belongs to the people who opened this video by riding hundreds of miles to the coast of Texas, the Comanche-speaking Uto-Aztecan language. As the name suggests, this family stretches across a vast area, from the Great Basin of Utah and Nevada all the way down into central Mexico.
14:58
It includes the Shoshone, the Ute, the Paiute, the Hopi of Arizona, the Tohono O'odham of the Sonoran Desert, the Yaqui and the Raramuri of northern Mexico, and, at the far southern end, Nahuatl, the language of the Aztecs.
15:13
That means the Comanche are distant linguistic cousins of the people who built Tenochtitlan. Several English words came into the language from Nahuatl through Spanish, including chocolate, tomato, avocado and chili. So the next time you order guacamole, you are technically using vocabulary from a distant relative of the Comanche language. History really does end up on your plate. The Comanche language is especially close to Shoshone, so close that speakers of the two could often understand each other. This is no accident. As we will see, the Comanche began as a branch of the Shoshone, living in the mountains and high basins of what is now Wyoming and the surrounding region.
15:50
Before they became the most feared riders of the southern plains, their ancestors were hunters and gatherers in a tough, dry landscape, moving with the seasons and living off small game, seeds and whatever the land offered. Humble beginnings, to put it mildly. If you had told a Shoshone band in the year 1500 that their descendants would one day dominate a territory larger than many European countries, they would probably have asked you to kindly sit down and drink some water. So there we have it. Four language families, five nations, and four completely separate starting points.
16:22
Iroquoian farmers around the Great Lakes, Suwan forest people on the upper Mississippi, Athabascan travellers drifting down from the far north, and Uto-Aztecan foragers in the high country of the Rockies and the Great Basin. but none of them lived in an empty world. Before any European ship appeared on the horizon, North America already had cities, monuments, trade networks and societies that had risen and fallen. Two of these deserve a closer look because they show just how much was going on before 1492. The first is Cahokia.
16:54
If you drive through southern Illinois today, just across the Mississippi River from St. Louis, you will pass something that looks at first like a large grassy hill. It is not a hill. It is Monk's Mound, a gigantic earthen platform built by hand, basket by basket, by people of what archaeologists call the Mississippian culture. It rises about 30 metres high, and its base covers more ground than the base of the Great Pyramid of Giza. No cranes, no trucks, no wheelbarrows, just millions of baskets of soil carried by human beings.
17:26
Imagine being the person in charge of scheduling that construction project. Every complaint about a slow office renovation suddenly feels very small. Cahokia took off around the year 1050, in such a rapid burst of growth that archaeologists sometimes call it the Big Bang.
17:43
Within a few decades, a modest settlement turned into a planned city with plazas, neighbourhoods, and more than a hundred mounds. Some mounds were platforms for important buildings and the homes of leaders. Others were burial mounds.
17:57
At its peak, Cahokia may have been home to somewhere between 10,000 and 20,000 people, with more living in the surrounding countryside. That would have put it in the same league as London at the same period. For centuries afterward, no city in what is now the United States would be as large. The people of Cahokia were skilled astronomers too. They raised circles of tall wooden posts that archaeologists nicknamed Wood Henge, which seemed to have tracked sunrise at the solstices and equinoxes. They also loved a game called Chunky. Players rolled a polished stone disc across a flat field and threw long poles at the spot where they thought the disc would stop.
18:33
It sounds simple, but it was taken very seriously, with crowds of spectators and bets that could reach dramatic levels.
18:41
Some accounts from later centuries describe people wagering nearly everything they owned on a single match. So if you thought sports betting was a modern invention, Cahokia would like a word.
18:51
but Cahokia did not last forever. By around 1350, the great city was largely abandoned. Researchers have suggested several causes, including floods, the cutting of too many trees, droughts, crop failures, political conflict, and simple social exhaustion.
19:09
Most likely it was a mix. The Mississippian world did not vanish all at once, though. Smaller chiefdoms continued to flourish across the southeast for centuries, and many later peoples carried pieces of that heritage in their art, their ceremonies, and their stories. Some scholars have even suggested links between Cahokia and certain Siuan-speaking peoples, such as the Osage and the Omaha, whose traditions and symbols share intriguing similarities with Mississippian ones.
19:36
It is not a settled question, but it shows how tangled and connected the ancient history of the continent really is.
19:42
Now let's travel southwest, to a landscape of red rock, canyons and dazzling sky.
19:49
This is the Four Corners region, where Utah, Colorado, Arizona and New Mexico meet. Here lived the ancestral Puebloans, the people whose descendants include the modern Hopi, Zuni, Acoma and the Pueblos of the Rio Grande Valley.
20:04
You may also come across an older name for them, Anasazi, but that word comes from the Navajo language and is often translated as ancestors of the enemies, so many Pueblo people today understandably prefer a different term. The ancestral Puebloans were master builders in stone. In Chaco Canyon, in northwestern New Mexico, they constructed what archaeologists call great houses, massive multi-storey buildings of carefully fitted sandstone. The largest, Pueblo Bonito, had somewhere around 600 to 800 rooms and rose four or five stories in places.
20:38
For centuries it was one of the largest buildings in North America and nothing in what became the United States clearly surpassed it until apartment blocks of the 1800s.
20:48
The builders also hauled tens of thousands of wooden beams from mountain forests located dozens of kilometres away, without wheels and without any pack animals.
20:56
Next time you struggle to get a sofa up a narrow staircase, spare a thought for the people of Chaco. Chaco was also connected by a network of remarkably straight roads, some running for many kilometres across the desert. They were up to nine metres wide, which is rather generous for a society with no carts and no horses. Some of these roads seem to lead nowhere in particular or run straight up cliffs using carved stairways. Archaeologists still argue about their purpose. Were they trade routes, ceremonial paths, symbols of power or all of the above?
21:29
Whatever the answer, someone clearly felt that a road should be straight even when common sense suggested a little curve might be easier. Later, in the 1200s, many ancestral Pueblans in the Mesa Verde region of southwestern Colorado moved into dwellings built under overhanging cliffs.
21:46
The most famous of these, Cliff Palace, contains around 150 rooms tucked into a sandstone alcove high above a canyon floor. To get home, residents climbed handholds and toeholds cut into the rock. It was excellent protection and terrible news for anyone who forgot their groceries at the bottom. Then came trouble. Tree ring records which let scientists read rainfall year by year show a severe drought between about 1276 and 1299. Combined with social tensions and probably conflict, it pushed the people of the Four Corners to leave the region almost entirely.
22:20
They did not disappear. They moved south and east, joining or founding communities along the Rio Grande, at Hopi and Zuni, and elsewhere. These became the pueblos that Spanish explorers would encounter in the 1500s. And here our story threads come together. The ancestral Puebloan migrations were happening at about the same time the Athabascan ancestors of the Navajo and Apache were arriving from the north.
22:44
The newcomers settled into the canyons and mazes around the pueblos, and the relationships that formed between them, sometimes trading partners, sometimes rivals, sometimes neighbours who borrowed ideas from each other, would shape the southwest for centuries. Of course, Cahokia and Chaco were only two highlights in a much bigger picture. Trade networks moved copper from the Great Lakes, shells from the Gulf of Mexico, obsidian from the Rocky Mountains, and turquoise from the southwest across astonishing distances.
23:13
Bright feathers of macaws, birds native to the tropics of Mexico, have even been found in Chaco Canyon. Ideas, songs, foods and technologies moved along those same routes. This was not a quiet, frozen world waiting for history to begin. It was a living continent full of experiments, successes, collapses and comebacks. And so we come back to our map. In the northeast, the Iroquois are farming the valleys of New York, building longer and longer houses, and dealing with neighbors in ways that are sometimes friendly and sometimes not.
23:45
On the upper Mississippi, the Suan ancestors of the Dakota, Lakota and Nakota are living among forests and lakes, still far from the plains that will later make them famous.
23:56
In the southwest, the Athabascan newcomers who will become the Navajo and Apache are settling into the country around the Pueblos, and in the high basins and mountains to the north, the Shoshone-speaking ancestors of the Comanche are living quietly as foragers with no idea of the empire waiting in their future. Each of these peoples will enter recorded history through a different door. For the Iroquois, the door is politics, an alliance so ambitious that it would one day catch the attention of the founders of the United States. For the Sioux and the Comanche, the door is a four-legged animal that had disappeared from the continent 10,000 years earlier and was about to make a spectacular return.
24:34
For the Navajo and the Apache, it is the meeting point between their own traditions, their Pueblo neighbors, and the Spanish frontier. Keep this map in your head because it is the one we will follow for the rest of the video. The first door to open belongs to the northeast. In the forests and river valleys of what is now New York, five nations that had spent generations locked in feuds were about to try something radical. They were going to agree to stop fighting each other, and they were going to write the rules down, not in ink, but in shell beads. The people we usually call the Iroquois have their own name for themselves, Haudenosaunee.
25:09
It is often translated as people of the longhouse, or more precisely, they who build the house. The word Iroquois itself came from the French, who probably borrowed it from a neighbouring language, and scholars still argue about what it originally meant. Some suggest it came from a word used by the Basque whalers who sailed to the Gulf of St. Lawrence, others from an Algonquian term that was not exactly a compliment. Either way, it is a bit like being known to the world by a nickname your rivals gave you. Tonight we will use both names, but keep in mind that the one with real meaning is Hodenosaunee.
25:42
That meaning is not poetic decoration. It is a political map.
25:46
the Haudenosaunee pictured their confederacy as one enormous longhouse stretching across what is now upstate New York, with each nation living under the same roof.
25:56
At the eastern end, guarding the door that faced the Hudson River and the Atlantic, lived the Mohawk, the keepers of the eastern door. At the western end, near the Genesee River and the lands toward Lake Erie, lived the Seneca, the keepers of the western door. Between them lived the Oneida and the Cayuga, and in the middle, at the heart of the house, lived the Onondaga, who tended the Central Council fire.
26:17
If you wanted to visit the Confederacy, you came through one of the doors. If you tried to come through the wall, things were unlikely to go well. But before there was one house, there were five nations that often treated each other as the main problem in life. According to Haudenosaunee tradition, the time before the Confederacy was an age of endless feuding. A killing in one village demanded revenge in another, which demanded revenge in return, and the cycle kept spinning.
26:43
Nobody could leave the village safely, hunting trips turned into risky gambles and grief was everywhere. Archaeology seems to back up at least part of this picture. As mentioned earlier, villages in this region were often protected by wooden palisades, sometimes several rows of them. People do not usually build three walls around their homes because they trust the neighbours.
27:04
Into this troubled world, the story says, came a man known as the Peacemaker. His personal name, Daganawida, is traditionally used with great respect, and many Haudenosaunee people prefer not to say it casually, which is why he is usually called simply the Peacemaker. According to tradition, he was born among the Wendat, north of Lake Ontario.
27:25
Even as a young man, he spoke about a new way of living, one based on peace, righteousness and power, with power meaning the strength that comes from unity.
27:34
The Wendat were not especially interested, so the peacemaker decided to take his message south across the lake. Here the story gives him a memorable means of transport. He's said to have crossed Lake Ontario in a canoe made of white stone. When he told people he planned to travel in a stone canoe, they understandably assumed the journey would be very short and very wet. but the canoe floated and he crossed the lake. It is the kind of entrance that makes people stop what they are doing and listen, which was presumably the point.
28:04
On the southern shore, one of the first people he met was a woman who lived beside a war trail and fed the warriors who passed through. In many versions of the story she's known as Jigonsa Se. The peacemaker shared his message with her and she accepted it. She became known as the mother of nations and her acceptance carries deep meaning in the tradition. The first person to embrace the great peace was a woman and from that moment women were given a central place in the new order. We will come back to exactly what that place was, because it is one of the most remarkable features of the whole system.
28:37
Next, the peacemaker went to the Mohawk. The Mohawk were cautious, and they wanted proof that this stranger had real spiritual power behind his words. So, in one well-known version of the story, the peacemaker agreed to a test. He climbed a tall tree growing at the edge of a waterfall, and the Mohawk cut the tree down, sending him into the rushing water below. They watched and waited and he did not come up. The next morning someone noticed smoke rising from a fire. There sat the peacemaker, calm and dry, ready to continue the conversation. The Mohawk decided that perhaps they should listen after all.
29:11
It is fair to say that very few job interviews in history have been quite this demanding.
29:15
The story's second great hero comes from a place of deep sorrow. His name was Hiawatha and according to tradition he was an Onondaga man, though he later lived among the Mohawk. Before you picture anything from school poetry, it is worth clearing up a famous mix-up.
29:31
In 1855, the American poet Henry Wadsworth Longfellow published The Song of Hiawatha, a long poem that made the name famous across the English-speaking world. The trouble is that Longfellow based his hero mostly on stories of an Ojibwe figure from the Great Lakes, then attached the name Hiawatha because he liked the sound of it. So the Hiawatha that millions of schoolchildren met in poetry class had very little to do with the real figure of Haudenosaunee tradition. Imagine writing a biography of George Washington and accidentally filling it with the life story of someone from Norway.
30:04
The Hiawatha of the great law story was a man shattered by loss. In the tradition, his daughters died during the years of conflict, and his grief was so overwhelming that he left his home and wandered through the forest.
30:17
At one point he came to a lake, and a flock of ducks rose from the surface all at once, lifting the water with them so that he could walk across the dry lake bed.
30:26
On the bottom he found small shells. He gathered them and strung them on cords, and he told himself that if he ever met someone who was grieving as deeply as he was, he would use these strings to comfort them. Instead, the one who found him was the peacemaker, and the peacemaker did something that nobody had done for Hiawatha before. He took the strings of shells and performed a ceremony of condolence. With each string he spoke words meant to heal a different part of the grieving person. He wiped away the tears from Hiawatha's eyes so he could see clearly again.
30:57
He cleared his ears so he could hear. He cleared his throat so he could speak and breathe freely. This ceremony, the condolence, became one of the foundations of Haudenosaunee life. It is still performed today, especially when a chief dies and a new one is raised up in his place. The idea behind it is simple and profound. A mind consumed by grief cannot make good decisions, so before people can talk about politics they must first help each other heal.
31:24
From then on, the peacemaker and Hiawatha worked as a team. Some traditions say that the peacemaker had difficulty speaking, so Hiawatha became his voice, explaining the message in words people could follow. It is a nice reminder that even the greatest ideas sometimes need a good spokesperson. Together they travelled from nation to nation. The Oneida accepted the message. So did the Cayuga. The Seneca were divided at first, but eventually they joined too. That left one nation and one very large problem. The problem had a name, Tadodaho.
31:56
He was a powerful leader among the Onondaga, and the tradition describes him as a terrifying figure. His body was twisted, his mind was full of bitterness and suspicion, and his hair was a mass of living, writhing snakes. It is safe to say he was not the kind of person you invite to dinner, and definitely not the kind you ask to sign a peace treaty.
32:17
In some versions of the story, Tadodaho was also responsible for the deaths of Hiawatha's daughters, which makes what happened next even more striking. The peacemaker and Hiawatha did not defeat Tadodaho with weapons. They approached him with the full strength of the other four nations behind them, along with songs, words of peace, and the support of Jigonsase.
32:38
Slowly, they won him over. Then, the story says, Hiawatha combed the snakes out of his hair, and the peacemaker straightened his twisted body. The crooked mind became straight as well, and in a move that any modern negotiator could learn from, they did not humiliate him. Instead, they offered him the most honoured position in the new Confederacy. The Onondaga would keep the Central Council fire, and Tadodaho would serve as its chair. To this day, the person who presides over the Grand Council carries the title Tadodaho.
33:09
You could call it the oldest recorded case of turning your toughest critic into the head of the committee.
33:14
To seal the new peace, the peacemaker planted a great white pine, the Tree of Peace, its four white roots stretched out in the four directions, so that any nation wishing to join the peace could follow a route back to its source and find shelter under its branches.
33:30
Beneath the tree, the leaders dug a hole and threw their weapons into it, then covered them up so that a deep underground current carried them away.
33:39
That image gave English one of its most famous expressions, to bury the hatchet.
33:44
On top of the tree sat an eagle, keeping watch in every direction so that it could cry out if danger approached. It is one of those rare cases where a powerful political symbol is also genuinely beautiful. Now for the question that has kept historians busy for over a century – when did all this actually happen? The honest answer is that nobody knows for sure and the proposed dates are spread across almost 500 years.
34:07
That is roughly the distance between the Battle of Hastings and the reign of Henry VIII in England. So this is not a small disagreement.
34:15
One of the most intriguing clues comes from the sky.
34:19
Some versions of the tradition say that when the Seneca finally agreed to join, the sun darkened in the middle of the day as if the heavens were giving their approval. If that refers to a real solar eclipse, then astronomy can help.
34:32
In the 1990s, the scholars Barbara Mann and Jerry Fields argued that the best match was a total eclipse visible over Seneca country on 31 August 1142.
34:43
That would make the Haudenosaunee Confederacy one of the oldest continuously functioning political unions in the world. Others point to a different eclipse in 1451 which would place the founding in the middle of the 15th century, the same era when Johannes Gutenberg was setting up his printing press in Germany.
34:59
Meanwhile, many archaeologists looking at village patterns, settlement sizes and signs of conflict argue for a later date, sometime in the 16th century or around the start of the 17th, perhaps only a few decades before Europeans began writing about the Five Nations. It is entirely possible that the Confederacy grew in stages, with some nations allying earlier and others joining later, so each of these dates might capture part of the truth.
35:24
Either way, it is not every day that a constitutional debate depends on checking an astronomical calendar. Whatever its exact birthday, the system created by the Great Law of Peace was impressively detailed. In the Mohawk language it's often called Kayanarekawa, the Great Good Way. It was not written on paper. It was kept in memory, in carefully preserved wampum, and in the speeches of people trained to recite it. A full recitation of the Great Law can take several days. That is the sort of document that makes modern terms and conditions look downright cheerful by comparison.
35:59
At the centre of the system stood the Grand Council. It was made up of fifty chiefs, often called Sahems in English, and known in Haudenosaunee languages by words such as Hoyone or Royone, which carry the sense of good men or men of the good path.
36:14
The fifty seats were not divided equally. The Onondaga, as keepers of the fire, held fourteen. The Cayuga held ten, the Mohawk and the Oneida held nine each, and the Seneca held eight.
36:26
If you are noticing that the Seneca, one of the largest nations, had the fewest seats, you have spotted something important. The council did not work by simple majority vote, so the number of chiefs mattered less than you might think. Instead, the Grand Council worked by consensus, through a carefully designed process. The nations were grouped like a family. The Mohawk and the Seneca were the elder brothers, and they sat on one side of the fire. The Ornada and the Cayuga were the younger brothers, and they sat on the other side, and later the Tuscarora joined them there.
36:58
When a matter came before the council, the elder brothers discussed it first and reached a joint position.
37:04
Then they passed it across the fire to the younger brothers, who discussed it in turn. If the two sides agreed, the matter went to the Onondaga, who confirmed the decision. If the sides disagreed, the Onondaga could send it back for further discussion or try to find a middle path. In other words, every decision had to pass through several rounds of debate and no single nation could simply push everyone else around. It was slow, deliberate and sometimes frustrating, but it was built to prevent hasty decisions and to keep the nations together.
37:35
The great law also had some lovely advice for the leaders themselves. A chief was expected to have a skin seven spans thick. That is to say, he should be so patient and steady that anger, insults and criticism would not penetrate. He should be calm when others shouted, generous when others were greedy, and focused on the welfare of the people rather than his own glory.
37:56
Many modern politicians would probably need a few extra spans. The Haudenosaunee are also widely associated with the principle of thinking about the seventh generation, considering how decisions made today will affect people living far into the future.
38:10
Whether that idea was spelled out in the original great law or developed in later teachings is debated, but it has become one of the most quoted ideas linked to the Confederacy. And now we arrive at the feature that sets this system apart from almost every political structure in Europe at the time, the role of women. Haudenosaunee society was matrilineal. That means a person belonged to the clan of their mother, not their father. Clans had names drawn from the natural world. The Mohawk and the Oneida had three, the Turtle, the Wolf and the Bear.
38:41
Other nations, like the Seneca, had more, including the Heron, the Hawk, the Snipe, the Beaver and the Deer.
38:48
A person had to marry someone from a different clan, and when a couple married, the husband usually moved into the longhouse of his wife's family. So the long row of relatives living under one roof was typically a group of related women, their husbands and their children. Each clan was led by a senior woman, known in English as the clan mother. And here is where the great law becomes truly striking. The fifty chief titles on the Grand Council were hereditary, but not in the way European titles were. They belonged to particular clans, and when a chief died or a seat became empty, it was the clan mother, after consulting with the women of her clan who chose the man to fill it.
39:25
She chose him. She could guide him, and if he failed to do his job, she could remove him. The process was carefully defined. If a chief acted against the good of the people, the clan mother would warn him. If he ignored the warning she would warn him again, this time with other witnesses. If he still refused to change she would give a third and final warning and then she could take away his title. This was called dehorning because a chief symbol of office was a set of deer antlers and removing them meant removing his authority. Picture a European king of the 1500s being told by his mother's family that he had three strikes before losing his crown.
40:03
The royal courts of Europe would have fainted. Women's influence did not stop there. They controlled the fields and the harvest, and the food stores of the village were in their hands. That gave them considerable say in matters of war. A war party needs food and spare moccasins, and if the women decided that a campaign was a bad idea, those supplies could become surprisingly hard to find. It is a quiet but effective veto.
40:28
Centuries later, this system impressed American women who were fighting for their own rights.
40:33
In the 19th century, activists such as Matilda Jocelyn Gage and Elizabeth Cady Stanton wrote admiringly about the authority of Haudenosaunee women. It is a nice historical coincidence that the famous Women's Rights Convention of 1848 was held in Seneca Falls, New York, in the heart of former Haudenosaunee country.
40:52
Of course, this does not mean that men had no role. Men served as chiefs on the council, led hunting expeditions, travelled for trade, carried out diplomacy and went to war.
41:02
A man might spend months away from the village, which is one reason the daily running of the community, along with the fields, the homes and the children, rested so firmly with the women. The two spheres complemented each other.
41:16
One way to put it is that women chose the leaders and men did the speaking, which makes the system feel strangely modern, like a board of directors and a group of executives who report to it.
41:26
The economic heart of this world was agriculture, and especially three crops known as the Three Sisters, corn, beans and squash.
41:35
Haudenosaunee tradition explains their origin in the creation story. Long ago a woman fell from the sky world through a hole in the heavens. Birds caught her and lowered her gently onto the back of a great turtle, and animals brought up mud from the bottom of the water to spread on the turtle's shell, which grew into the land. That is why many native peoples of the region call North America Turtle Island.
41:57
When Sky Woman's daughter died, plants grew from her body, and among them were corn, beans, and squash, the gifts that would feed her descendants.
42:07
The three sisters were not just a nice story. They were also an excellent farming system. Women planted them together in small mounds of earth. The corn grew tall and straight, giving the beans something to climb. The beans, like all legumes, helped return nitrogen to the soil, keeping it fertile. The big broad leaves of the squash spread across the ground, shading the soil, keeping it moist and discouraging weeds. And on the dinner plate, the three crops complemented each other nutritionally as well, providing a balanced mix that kept people healthy through long winters.
42:39
In other words, the Haudenosaunee had a companion planting system centuries before gardening magazines started writing articles about it.
42:47
Men did their part by clearing land, cutting down trees and burning off the brush to open new fields. Women then took over the planting, weeding, harvesting and storing. Corn was dried and kept in bark-lined pits and storage areas, and it could be pounded into flour, made into soups and breads, or carried as a light travel food. Because the fields slowly lost their fertility and because firewood nearby was gradually used up, villages usually move to a new site every 10 to 20 years. So imagine packing up your entire town, house by house, and rebuilding it a few kilometres away every couple of decades.
43:23
It puts the stress of a normal moving day into perspective. Then there was the longhouse itself, the building that gave the people their name. A typical longhouse was framed with wooden poles bent into an arch and covered with large sheets of elm bark. It was usually around six or seven metres wide, and its length varied with the size of the family living inside, often somewhere between twenty and sixty metres. Some were even longer, and archaeologists have found remains of houses stretching beyond a hundred metres. When a new family joined, the house could simply be extended.
43:55
It was the original expandable home. Inside, a long corridor ran down the centre. Along it, every few metres, there was a fire and each fire was shared by two families, one on each side of the corridor.
44:07
Those families lived on raised wooden platforms that served as beds and seating, with more shelves above for storage. A longhouse could hold several of these fires, and dozens of people lived under its roof, all related through the women of the house. Above each fire there was a hole in the roof to let the smoke out, in theory.
44:26
In practice the smoke did not always cooperate. French missionaries who stayed in longhouses in the 17th century complained in their letters about stinging eyes, coughing, and the smell of smoke that soaked into everything they owned.
44:40
Add to that the dogs, the children, the conversations, and the complete lack of privacy, and you have a home that was warm, lively, and very much not designed for introverts. Above the door at each end the house often displayed the symbol of the clan that lived inside, so visitors could tell at a glance whose home they were entering. Now, a system as complex as the Great Law needed a way to keep records, and this is where Wampum enters the story. Wampum are small, tube-shaped beads made from shells. The white beads came mostly from the whelk, a type of sea snail, and the purple ones from the quahog, a hard-shelled clam found along the Atlantic coast.
45:17
Making them was slow, demanding work. Each bead had to be cut, shaped, polished and then drilled through the centre, originally with stone tools, a process that could take a very long time for a single bead.
45:30
So a large wampum belt containing thousands of beads represented an enormous amount of labour and was correspondingly precious.
45:37
Wampum came in strings and in woven belts. Strings were used for messages, invitations and ceremonies, such as the condolence that Hiawatha first created.
45:47
Belts were used for the most important matters, including treaties, alliances and the founding principles of the Confederacy itself.
45:55
The patterns woven into a belt, made from contrasting white and purple beads, served as a memory device. Each design represented particular words and agreements, and trained wampum keepers could read a belt and recite the meaning behind it.
46:09
White beads usually stood for peace, purity, and goodwill, while the darker purple beads marked serious or solemn matters. When a speaker addressed a council, he would often hold a belt or string in his hands, and when he finished an important point he would hand it over. Without the wampum, a proposal was simply words in the air. With the wampum, it became an official commitment.
46:32
The phrase putting it on the record took a very literal form here. The most famous belt of all is the Hiawatha belt. Its design shows four squares, linked by a line, connected to a central figure often described as a tree or a heart. The squares represent the Mohawk, the Oneida, the Cayuga and the Seneca. and the central symbol represents the Onondaga, the keepers of the fire, holding the whole Union together. Today, that same design appears on the flag of the Haudenosaunee Confederacy, which makes it one of the oldest national symbols in North America still in use.
47:05
The belts were kept at Onondaga under the care of a designated keeper, effectively making it the national archive of the Confederacy, although with considerably fewer filing cabinets. For centuries, the Confederacy was known as the Five Nations. Then, in the early 18th century it grew, the newcomers were the Tuscarora, an Iroquoian-speaking people from what is now North Carolina. As mentioned earlier, they belonged to the same language family as the Five Nations, but they had been living far to the south for many generations. In the early 1700s, colonial expansion in the Carolinas put them under heavy pressure.
47:40
Settlers moved onto their land, traders cheated them, and many Tuscarora were captured and sold into slavery. These tensions exploded into the Tuscarora War, which broke out in 1711 and ended a few years later with a devastating defeat for the Tuscarora.
47:57
Many survivors decided that staying in the south was no longer possible. Over the following years, large numbers of them travelled north a journey of hundreds of kilometres to seek shelter with their distant relatives.
48:10
The Oneida took them under their protection and allowed them to settle on their lands.
48:15
Around 1722, the Tuscarora were formally adopted into the Confederacy and the Five Nations became the Six Nations.
48:23
In the image of the Tree of Peace, they had followed one of its white roots all the way back to the shelter of its branches.
48:29
In a way, it was the system working exactly as it had been designed, a union that could take in a people in trouble and offer them a place in the house. There was a catch, however. The Tuscarora did not receive their own seats on the Grand Council. They were represented through the Oneida, a bit like a younger sibling who's allowed at the family table, but still has to ask an older sibling to speak up on their behalf.
48:52
Even so, their adoption marked the Confederacy's evolution into the form that is still known today.
48:58
By the early eighteenth century then, the Haudenosaunee had built something extraordinary, a league of nations with a shared constitution, a council that ruled by consensus, a careful balance of power between nations and between men and women, and a recording system woven out of shell beads.
49:15
They had the Three Sisters in their fields, crowded and smoky longhouses in their villages, and a political tradition that could absorb newcomers and endure for generations.
49:25
But even before the Tuscarora arrived, the world around the Longhouse had begun to change in ways that the peacemaker could never have imagined. Strangers had arrived from across the ocean carrying iron tools, cloth and firearms, and these strangers wanted one thing above almost everything else. Not gold, not spices, not land, at least not at first. They wanted beaver fur because back in Europe, the most fashionable people were going absolutely wild for a particular kind of hat.
49:54
To understand why a hat could reshape the politics of a continent, we have to look at a very specific European obsession. From the late 16th century onward, the must-have accessory for any fashionable man in Europe was a broad-brimmed hat made of felt. and the very best felt, the kind that held its shape in the rain, kept a crisp brim, and announced to everyone that you were a person of means, was made from beaver fur. Not the glossy outer hairs, but the soft, dense under-fur, whose tiny barbs locked together perfectly when pressed and heated.
50:26
A good beaver hat could cost a small fortune, and it was the kind of item people listed in their wills. There was one problem. Europe had largely run out of beavers. Centuries of trapping had wiped them out across most of Western Europe, and the remaining supply from Scandinavia and Russia could not keep up with demand.
50:44
So when European ships reached the north-eastern coast of North America and found rivers and lakes packed with beavers, the reaction among merchants was something close to pure joy. A whole continent of hat material was waiting. The only catch was that someone had to trap the animals, prepare the pelts, and bring them to the trading posts, and that someone was going to be the native peoples who knew the land. It is worth adding, as a side note, that the hatmakers back in Europe did not have a great time either. The felting process later involved compounds of mercury, which slowly poisoned the workers and caused trembling and confusion.
51:19
That is one popular explanation for the phrase mad as a hatter. Fashion has always demanded sacrifices, but usually not quite this many.
51:28
For the Haudenosaunee, this new European appetite opened up opportunities and dangers in equal measure. In exchange for furs, Europeans offered goods that quickly became essential. Iron axes that did not shatter like stone, copper kettles that could be set straight on a fire, steel knives, needles, woven cloth, glass beads, and most important of all, firearms. A people with iron tools and guns had an enormous advantage over a people without them, and every nation in the region understood that very quickly.
51:57
The first major European power to arrive in the area was France. French traders and explorers built their base along the St. Lawrence River and their main trading partners were the Wendat, whom we already met as the Huron and various Algonquian-speaking peoples to the north.
52:13
Unfortunately for French relations with the Haudenosaunee, one of their very first encounters set a terrible tone. In 1609, the explorer Samuel de Champlain joined a war party of his native allies heading south into the lake that now bears his name. There they met a group of Mohawk warriors. When the two sides lined up, Champlain stepped forward and fired his arquebus, an early type of gun, and two Mohawk leaders fell.
52:37
The Mohawk had never faced firearms before and they retreated. For the French, it was a dramatic first impression. For the Mohawk, it was a reason to remember the French as enemies for a very long time. As diplomatic introductions go, it ranks somewhere near the bottom. The Haudenosaunee needed a European partner of their own and in the same year of 1609, one arrived from the other direction.
52:59
the English captain Henry Hudson, sailing for the Dutch, made his way up the river that now carries his name. Within a few years Dutch traders were doing business in the region, and in 1624 they built Fort Orange, on the spot where the city of Albany stands today. It sat right on the edge of Mohawk country, practically on their doorstep at the eastern door of the longhouse. According to Haudenosaunee tradition, an agreement with the Dutch around this time was recorded in a famous wampum belt called the two-row wampum, often dated to 1613. Its design is simple and elegant.
53:32
Two parallel rows of purple beads run along a white background. One row represents a Haudenosaunee canoe, the other a European ship. They travel side by side down the River of Life, sharing the same water, but neither one tries to steer the other. Historians argue about the authenticity of a written document that claims to record this treaty, but the belt and its meaning remain central to Haudenosaunee thinking about their relationships with outsiders to this day. It is essentially the world's oldest version of a very polite request to mind your own business while remaining friends.
54:06
The Dutch, meanwhile, discovered that wampum was incredibly useful. Coins were scarce in the young colony of New Netherland and native trading partners valued wampum highly.
54:16
So the Dutch began using shell beads as actual money and for a while wampum was legal tender in the colony. Then colonists got the bright idea of making their own beads with steel drills, which was far faster than the old stone methods. Production soared and so did the supply of wampum and its value inevitably fell. In other words, North America's first currency crisis was caused by bead inflation. Economists would have had a field day. The Dutch trade gave the Mohawk access to firearms, sometimes in defiance of Dutch rules and later more openly.
54:49
By the 1640s, the Mohawk had several hundred guns, far more than most of their neighbours, and they had a growing reason to use them. The beaver supply in their own homeland was running out fast.
55:01
Trapping for the European market had stripped the rivers and streams of Haudenosaunee country, and the nations of the Confederacy now needed furs from somewhere else to keep buying the goods they had come to depend on.
55:13
The richest beaverlands lay to the north and west in the territories of the Wendat and their allies, who were also the main suppliers of the French. You can probably see where this is heading. There was another force pushing the Haudenosaunee toward war, and it was invisible.
55:27
European diseases had arrived in the northeast ahead of most Europeans themselves. Smallpox, measles, and other illnesses to which native peoples had no prior immunity spread along trade routes. In the 1630s and 1640s, epidemics tore through the villages of the region. The Haudenosaunee and the Wendat may both have lost around half of their populations in a matter of years. It is hard to overstate what that meant. Entire families vanished, and longhouses that had been full of life stood half empty. This is where an old tradition took on a new urgent role, how Denisoni society practised what historians call mourning wars.
56:04
When a person died, especially in large numbers, the grieving clan mothers could ask the men to bring back captives from enemy nations to fill the empty places.
56:13
Some captives met a harsh fate, but many were adopted. In a ceremony sometimes called requickening, an adopted captive could be given the name of a deceased person and take over their role in the family, becoming a son, a daughter, a brother or a sister.
56:28
To modernize it is a startling idea, being taken from your home by force and then welcomed into a new family as a replacement for someone you never met, but for the Haudenosaunee it was a way of keeping the community alive, of literally putting people back into the house.
56:42
As the epidemics grew worse, the demand for captives rose, and so did the scale of the raids.
56:48
By the middle of the 17th century, French missionaries reported that in some Haudenosaunee villages adopted outsiders made up a large share of the population, perhaps even a majority.
56:59
the Confederacy was surviving by absorbing its rivals, one family at a time. All of this, the hunger for furs, the need for captives, the access to Dutch guns, came together in a long series of conflicts known as the Beaver Wars. They lasted with pauses and changes of direction from around the 1640s until 1701.
57:19
The name is a little misleading since the wars were about much more than beavers. They were about trade routes, hunting territories, political power and, as we have just seen, the very survival of communities hit by disease. But it is also true that very few wars in history can be traced so directly back to a hat. The decisive blow fell on the Wendat. Before the epidemics, the Wendat Confederacy had been one of the largest and most prosperous societies in the region, with perhaps 20,000 to 30,000 people living in fortified towns between Lake Huron and Lake Simcoe in what is now Ontario.
57:53
They were skilled farmers and the main middlemen of the French fur trade, but by the late 1640s disease had cut their numbers roughly in half and the society was also deeply divided between those who had accepted Christianity from the French Jesuit missionaries and those who had not.
58:09
In March of 1649 a large Haudenosaunee war party, mostly Mohawk and Seneca, struck deep into Wendat country in the middle of winter when nobody expected them. They captured two important towns in quick succession. The shock was enormous. Within weeks, the Wendat abandoned and burned their own remaining villages rather than leave them to the attackers and the people scattered. The French Jesuits, who had built an impressive mission called Saint-Marie among the Hurons, set fire to it themselves before leaving.
58:40
Some Wendat fled to an island in Georgian Bay, where they spent a desperate winter with very little food. Some made their way east to the French settlements near Quebec, where their descendants still live today in the community of Wendake. Others travelled west and later became known as the Wyandotte, and a large number were absorbed into the Haudenosaunee nations themselves through the adoption practices we just mentioned. The Wendat Confederacy, as a unified power, had ceased to exist almost overnight. The Confederacy did not stop there. In the following years, they dispersed several other neighbouring peoples, including the Petun, the Neutral Nation, and the Eyrie, many of whom were also adopted into Haudenosaunee communities.
59:21
Their war parties ranged far to the west and south, reaching the Ohio Valley, the Illinois Country, and the upper Great Lakes. For a time, the Haudenosaunee were the most feared military power in north-eastern North America. The French, who had lost their main trading partners and found themselves under repeated attack, did not take this quietly.
59:42
In 1666 a French army marched into Mohawk country and burned several villages and their stored food, forcing a peace. In 1687 another French expedition struck the Seneca, and in 1689 Haudenosaunee warriors answered with a raid on the settlement of Lachine just outside Montreal, which spread terror throughout New France. Then the French responded again, and so on.
60:07
By the 1690s, everyone involved was exhausted and the Confederacy itself was paying a heavy price, with many of its warriors lost and its population under severe strain. It was becoming clear that this cycle had to end.
60:21
The end came in the summer of 1701 in the city of Montreal. It was one of the most remarkable diplomatic gatherings in the history of North America. The French governor, Louis-Héctor de Calier, invited the Haudenosaunee and their many former enemies to negotiate a general peace.
60:37
Around 1,300 delegates arrived, representing about 40 native nations from across the Great Lakes, the St. Lawrence Valley and beyond. They came by canoe from hundreds of kilometres away. Imagine organising a summit for 40 nations, many of whom have been at war with each other for decades, without email, without phones and without a single interpreter who could speak all the languages. The logistics alone deserve a medal. One of the most influential figures at the conference was a Wendat leader named Condiaronc, whom the French nicknamed the Rat.
61:09
He was famous for his intelligence, his eloquence and his sharp wit, and he was a skilled debater who had argued with French officials about religion and society for years, often leaving them without a good reply. At Montreal he worked tirelessly to bring the various nations together and to persuade them that peace served everyone. Then, in the middle of the negotiations, he fell seriously ill. He gave a powerful speech to the assembly while barely able to stand, and he died the next day.
61:37
The French gave him a grand funeral with full military honours. A few days later, on the 4th of August, 1701, the Great Peace of Montreal was concluded.
61:47
The leaders of the nations mark the treaty not with written signatures, but with the symbols of their clans and peoples, drawn as small pictures on the document. A turtle, a bear, a deer, a crane. It is one of the most charming signature pages ever produced, and one of the most consequential.
62:07
For the Haudenosaunee, the great peace marked a turning point. The age of large-scale wars against their neighbours to the north and west came to an end, and the Confederacy adopted a new strategy. Instead of fighting the European powers or their allies, they would balance between them.
62:24
In the very same summer, and this is a perfect example of the new approach, Haudenosaunee representatives also met with English officials at Albany and agreed to place their western hunting grounds under the protection of the English crown. So in one season they made peace with France in Montreal and signed a protection agreement with England in Albany. You could call it hedging your bets. The Confederacy would call it smart diplomacy and for much of the 18th century it worked. As long as the French and the British both needed the Haudenosaunee, neither could afford to ignore them and the Confederacy could extract gifts, trade benefits and respect from both sides.
63:01
They were the swing state of colonial North America. Their relationship with the English, and later the British, was organised through an alliance known as the Covenant Chain. It began in the 1670s with agreements between the Haudenosaunee and the colony of New York. which had taken over from the Dutch, and it gradually grew to include other colonies and native nations. The metaphor behind it was a chain linking a Haudenosaunee longhouse to an English ship. At first it was described as a chain of iron, but iron rusts, so it became a chain of silver, which can be kept bright, and a silver chain needs regular polishing.
63:37
That meant both sides had to meet periodically, renew their commitments, exchange gifts, and talk through problems.
63:44
These councils, often held at Albany, were major events, with speeches, wampum, feasts and long negotiations.
63:53
It was a relationship that needed constant maintenance, which is true of most good relationships. Through the covenant chain, the Haudenosaunee also positioned themselves as spokesmen for other native peoples in the region. The British found it convenient to negotiate with the Confederacy as if it spoke for the Lenape, also known as the Delaware, the Shawnee and others, and the Haudenosaunee were happy to accept that role since it increased their influence.
64:17
The Lenape and the Shawnee, unsurprisingly, were much less enthusiastic about having someone else speak for them. It was a recipe for future resentment and it would come back to haunt everyone involved.
64:29
One of the most famous moments in this diplomatic world took place in 1744 at a treaty conference in the town of Lancaster, Pennsylvania. An Onondaga leader named Kanasatigo addressed the representatives of several British colonies who were constantly quarrelling with one another. He gave them some friendly advice. His ancestors, he explained, had found that unity made them strong and respected among their neighbours, and the colonists would do well to follow their example and join together in the same way. It is a little like a neighbour leaning over the fence and suggesting that maybe you should stop arguing with your relatives in the driveway.
65:03
The proceedings of this treaty were printed and sold by a Philadelphia publisher who was very interested in the subject. His name was Benjamin Franklin.
65:12
Ten years later, in 1754, delegates from seven British colonies met at Albany with Howden-Sawney leaders. War with France was looming once again and the British urgently needed to repair the Covenant chain. A Mohawk leader named Hendrik Theonogun delivered a blunt speech, criticising the colonists for neglecting their alliance, for their weak defences and for their constant disputes over land.
65:37
At the same meeting, Franklin presented his Albany Plan of Union, a proposal for the colonies to form a joint government with a shared council to handle defence and relations with native nations.
65:48
Franklin had already written to a colleague a few years earlier that if the six nations could create such a durable union, it would be strange indeed if a dozen English colonies could not manage something similar. He expressed it in the condescending language of his time, but the point was clear. The Haudenosaunee example was on his mind. The colonies and the British government both rejected his plan, as it turned out. Nobody in Albany wanted to share power.
66:13
But the idea of a union did not go away. That brings us to one of the most debated questions about the Haudenosaunee. Did their confederacy influence the constitution of the United States? Some historians argue that it did. The founders knew about the confederacy, some of them had attended treaty councils, and the idea of separate states uniting under a common government with shared authority looks, at first glance, quite similar.
66:37
In 1988, the United States Congress passed a resolution officially acknowledging the contribution of the Iroquois Confederacy to the development of the Constitution.
66:47
Many other historians, however, are skeptical. They point out that the founders drew mainly on European political thinkers, on ancient Greece and Rome, and on their own colonial experience, and that the American system differs from the Haudenosaunee one in important ways.
67:03
The Constitution relies on majority voting rather than consensus, for example, and it gave women no political role at all, which is quite a contrast with the clan mothers we met earlier.
67:14
The truth probably lies somewhere in the middle. The Confederacy was a living example of a union of separate nations that worked, and it was right there in front of the colonists. Whether it inspired specific clauses or simply showed that such a union was possible, it was part of the conversation.
67:30
Meanwhile, the Confederacy was being pulled deeper into the rivalry between Britain and France. During the French and Indian War, which began in 1754, many Mohawk fought alongside the British, and Hendrick himself died in battle near Lake George in 1755.
67:46
The British Superintendent of Indian Affairs, Sir William Johnson, became a central figure in these relationships. He lived in the Mohawk Valley, spoke Mohawk, and had a long partnership with a remarkable Mohawk woman named Molly Brandt, who was highly influential in her own right.
68:02
Her younger brother, Joseph Brandt, would soon become one of the most famous native leaders of the century. When France lost the war in 1763 and gave up its North American empire, the Haudenosaunee lost their most valuable asset, the ability to play two empires against each other. There was now only one empire left in the region and the next crisis was about to come from within it. That crisis was the American Revolution.
68:26
When the 13 colonies rebelled against Britain, both sides wanted the Haudenosaunee on their side, or at least out of the way.
68:34
At first, the Confederacy tried to remain neutral, which was consistent with the policy that had served them so well for decades.
68:41
But this war was different. It was not a contest between two foreign empires.
68:47
It was a civil war among the British themselves, and the lines ran right through the Haudenosaunee world. Each nation, and sometimes each village, had to decide for itself.
68:57
Joseph Brandt, whose Mohawk name was Thayendanagea, was the most prominent voice for supporting the British. He had been educated at a colonial school in Connecticut, spoke and wrote English well and translated parts of the Bible into Mohawk. In 1775 he travelled to London where he met King George III, sat for a portrait by the famous painter George Romney and became something of a celebrity and fashionable society.
69:23
It is a remarkable picture, a Mohawk diplomat touring the drawing-rooms of London while his homeland teetered on the edge of war.
69:30
Brandt came away convinced that the British crown was a better guarantee of Mohawk lands than the colonists, whose hunger for territory he knew very well.
69:39
Most of the Mohawk, Seneca, Cayuga and Onondaga eventually sided with Britain. The Oneida and the Tuscarora took the other path. They had close ties with a Presbyterian missionary named Samuel Kirkland, who supported the rebels, and they had their own reasons to distrust some of their neighbours.
69:57
Oneida warriors fought alongside American troops, and according to a well-known tradition, Oneida people carried hundreds of bushels of corn to the starving soldiers of George Washington's army during the brutal winter at Valley Forge. One Oneida woman, Polly Cooper, is said to have stayed to teach the soldiers how to prepare the corn, since they did not know how to cook it properly. Considering how hungry they were, that lesson was probably appreciated.
70:22
In 1777, unable to agree on a common position, the Grand Council took a heartbreaking step.
70:29
The council fire at Onondaga was covered, a sign that the Confederacy could no longer act as one.
70:35
That same year, at the Battle of Orescani in the Mohawk Valley, Seneca and Mohawk warriors fighting with the British faced Anada warriors fighting with the Americans. For a union founded on the idea that its nations would never again turn on each other, it was a tragic moment.
70:50
The great peace had held for generations, and now the war of strangers had split the house. In 1779, the American side decided to strike at the heart of Haudenosaunee country. George Washington ordered a major campaign, led by General John Sullivan and General James Clinton, against the nations allied with Britain.
71:10
Around 4,000 soldiers marched into Seneca and Cayuga territory in what is now western New York.
71:17
The Haudenosaunee mostly withdrew ahead of them, so the campaign became less a series of battles and more a systematic destruction of homes and food.
71:25
The soldiers burned around 40 villages, cut down orchards and destroyed huge quantities of corn, beans and squash. American officers wrote in their journals with genuine surprise about the size of the fields and the quality of the houses they found.
71:39
Many had expected rough forest camps, and instead they found well-built towns with large orchards. The surprise did not stop them from burning everything. Thousands of Holdenosaunee refugees fled to the British fort at Niagara, where they spent a bitterly cold winter short on food and shelter.
71:56
The Seneca already had a name for Washington, inherited from earlier dealings with his family, which can be translated as town destroyer.
72:05
After 1779, it fit him all too well.
72:09
When the war ended in 1783, the British and the Americans signed the Treaty of Paris.
72:15
It drew new borders across North America and it did not mention Britain's native allies at all.
72:20
The lands of the Haudenosaunee, including those of the nations that had fought for the king, were simply included within the borders of the new United States, as though nobody lived there. Joseph Brandt and other leaders were furious. They had fought and lost homes for the British crown, and now they had been left out of the peace entirely. It was not the first time a European power forgot its allies at the negotiating table, and it would certainly not be the last.
72:46
The British tried to make amends. In 1784, the Governor of Quebec, Frederick Haldimond, granted the Mohawk and other Hadunsawny allies a large tract of land along the Grand River in what is now southern Ontario. The grant was generous on paper, covering six miles on each side of the river from its source to its mouth.
73:05
Joseph Brandt led a large group of Hildenosaunee there and they established a new community. The nearby city of Brantford is named after him. The Mohawk built a chapel there in 1785 which still stands as one of the oldest buildings in Ontario. Today, the Six Nations of the Grand River is the most populous First Nations reserve in all of Canada, although over the centuries much of the original grant was sold, leased or lost, a subject of disputes that continue to this day.
73:33
another group of Mohawks settled at the Bay of Quinty on Lake Ontario in a community known today as Tiendinaga.
73:40
Those Haudenosaunee who stayed in the new United States, including the Oneida who had fought for the American cause, faced enormous pressure to give up their lands through a long series of treaties and sales. One of these agreements, the Treaty of Canandaigua, signed in 1794 between the United States and the Six Nations, has an unusual detail that has survived into the present.
74:02
As part of the treaty, the United States promised to provide an annual payment that included cloth, and the United States still does it.
74:10
Every year, a delivery of cotton cloth is made to the Haudenosaunee, a small but symbolic reminder that the treaty is still considered in force. Few government commitments have lasted more than two centuries, and even fewer involve fabric, so by the end of the 18th century the Haudenosaunee world had been transformed, The beaver had made them rich and then drawn them into war. The Great Peace of Montreal had turned them into masters of diplomacy, balancing empires against each other for most of a century. Then the revolution had split the house in two, with one part now in Canada and another in the United States.
74:45
The Confederacy endured and its council fire would be rekindled on both sides of the border.
74:51
But its era as a great power broker between rival empires was over.
74:55
While the Haudenosaunee were dealing with hats, guns and colonial congresses in the northeast, something very different was unfolding 2,000 kilometres to the southwest. It had begun in 1680, in the dry valley of the Rio Grande, with a carefully planned uprising and a cord full of knots. and it set loose an animal that would change everything we think we know about the native peoples of the American West. The Spanish had arrived in New Mexico in 1598, when an expedition led by Juan de Oñate pushed north from Mexico along the Rio Grande and claimed the land and the people living on it for the Spanish crown.
75:31
The people in question were the Pueblo Nations, the descendants of the ancestral Puebloan builders we met earlier, who lived in compact towns of stone and adobe and farmed the river valleys. For the next 80 years, Spanish rule in New Mexico rested on a heavy foundation.
75:48
Pueblo communities were required to deliver tribute in corn, cotton cloth and labour to Spanish colonists.
75:54
Franciscan missionaries built churches in the pueblos and worked hard to stamp out traditional religion, raiding the underground ceremonial chambers known as kivas and destroying sacred masks and objects.
76:06
Governors and priests often quarrelled with each other over who had the right to command pueblo labour, which tells you something about how the colony saw the pueblo people. They were essentially a resource to be argued over.
76:18
By the 1670s, things were getting worse. A long drought struck the region, crops failed, and hunger spread. Raids by Apache groups increased, partly because they were suffering from the same drought. And Spanish authorities, seeing the troubles as a sign that the old religion was making a comeback, cracked down harder.
76:38
In 1675, the governor arrested 47 Pueblo religious leaders on charges of sorcery. Several were executed and the rest were publicly punished and imprisoned. Then a group of Pueblo warriors showed up at the governor's office in Santa Fe and politely, but very firmly, asked for the prisoners to be released.
76:57
The governor, looking at the number of armed men in front of him, decided that mercy was suddenly a very attractive option.
77:04
One of the released men was a religious leader from the pueblo of Okai Owinge, known in history as Popay or Popay.
77:12
He did not forget what had happened. Over the next five years, he and other leaders quietly organized something that nobody in the region had ever attempted before. a coordinated uprising of dozens of pueblos spread across hundreds of kilometres, speaking several different languages. That last detail matters because the pueblo nations did not share a single language and they had not always been close allies.
77:35
Getting them to agree on anything was a major achievement. Getting them to agree on a secret date was nothing short of a miracle. The method they used was brilliantly simple. Runners carried cords made of yucca fibre tied with a set number of knots from Pueblo to Pueblo. Each day, the leaders in every community would untie one knot. When the last knot was undone, everyone would rise at the same time. It was a countdown clock that needed no clock, no calendar and no written message that the Spanish might intercept.
78:07
The plan was nearly ruined when Spanish officials captured two of the runners and learned what was going on. so the leaders moved the date forward and the revolt began on 10 August 1680 ahead of schedule. The Spanish were caught completely off guard. Across the colony, Pueblo fighters attacked missions, ranches and settlements. Hundreds of colonists were killed, including 21 Franciscan priests. the survivors gathered in Santa Fe, where the governor, Antonio de Otamín, found himself besieged in the government buildings.
78:39
After several days, with the water supply cut off, he led roughly 2,000 Spanish survivors on a long retreat south, all the way to El Paso.
78:48
For the first time, a European colonial power had been completely driven out of a major region of North America by the people it ruled. The Pueblo nations would stay independent for 12 years until Diego de Vargas led a Spanish return in 1692. Spain did come back, but it came back more cautious. The missionaries in the new era were noticeably less eager to burn sacred objects, and the most abusive forms of forced labour were reduced. Sometimes the lessons of history are learned the hard way, but at least they are learned.
79:18
Now, all of this is a fascinating story on its own. But for the rest of the continent, the most important result of the Pueblo Revolt had four legs. When the Spanish fled New Mexico, they left behind large numbers of horses. Spanish ranches, missions and settlements had kept herds for decades, and now those herds were in Pueblo hands.
79:38
There was an important legal detail here too. Spanish law in the colonies generally forbade native people from owning horses or riding them without special permission.
79:48
The authorities understood perfectly well that a mounted native population would be much harder to control.
79:54
But the Spanish also needed someone to take care of all those animals and that someone was often Pueblo herders and stable hands. So the Pueblo people knew how to handle horses, how to train them and how to breed them. They just had not been allowed to keep them.
80:09
After 1680 that rule no longer applied. In truth, horses had already been slipping out of Spanish control before the revolt.
80:17
Some had been traded illegally, some had been stolen by Apache and Ute raiders, and a few had simply run off.
80:24
But after 1680, the trickle became a flood. Pueblo communities traded horses to their neighbors at the great trade fairs held at places like Taos and Pecos, where peoples of the plains came to exchange buffalo hides and meat for corn, pottery, and cloth.
80:40
Apache groups, Ute bands, and others began acquiring horses in significant numbers. From there, the animals moved north and east, passed from one people to another through trade, gifts, raids and capture of wild herds.
80:56
There is a wonderful irony in all of this, and you may remember the clue from earlier. Horses were not foreigners in North America. As we saw, the horse family actually evolved on this continent over millions of years before disappearing at the end of the Ice Age. so when Spanish horses galloped north from the Rio Grande, they were, in a sense, simply coming home after a long 10,000-year vacation in Asia and Europe. They found the grasslands of the Great Plains very much to their liking. The climate suited them, the grass was abundant and before long wild herds of escaped horses, known as mustangs, were spreading across the open country as well.
81:33
The speed of the spread was astonishing. By around 1700 horses were common among peoples on the southern and central plains. The Comanche, whose rise we will follow shortly, acquired them around this time.
81:45
By the 1730s horses had reached the peoples of the northern plains, including the Blackfoot in what is now Montana and Alberta.
81:53
By the middle of the 18th century, they were found almost everywhere between the Rio Grande and the Saskatchewan River, a distance of well over 2,000 kilometres. In the span of just a few generations, a whole continent's worth of peoples had to figure out what to do with an animal none of their grandparents had ever seen.
82:10
Many of them described the newcomer by comparing it to the most useful animal they already knew, the dog. The Lakota came to call the horse by a name that means something like sacred dog or mysterious dog. The Blackfoot spoke of the elk dog, an animal as big as an elk that did the work of a dog. This makes perfect sense once you understand how people on the plains had lived before. Before horses, life on the plains was organised around walking and around dogs. Historians sometimes call this time the dog days.
82:40
Dogs were the only beasts of burden and they pulled a simple device called a travoir – two long poles tied together at one end, with a frame or platform lashed between them to carry a load.
82:50
A strong dog could pull perhaps 20 to 30 kilograms. That meant a family's entire set of belongings had to be kept small and light. Teepees were smaller because the poles and hide covers had to be carried. Camps could only move a modest distance in a day – perhaps 8 or 10 kilometres – and dogs had their own opinions. They fought each other, chased rabbits at the worst possible moment and occasionally decided that the load they were pulling looked more like a snack.
83:17
Moving camp was a noisy, chaotic and probably very entertaining process. The horse changed all of that. A single horse could pull or carry several times more than a dog and it could cover far longer distances in a day. Suddenly a family could own more things. Tippis grew larger, with longer poles and bigger covers made from more hides. People could carry more food, more tools, more clothing and more ceremonial objects. They could travel farther to find bison, to trade, to visit relatives and to go to war.
83:47
The size of the world in a very practical sense expanded overnight.
83:51
Hunting changed most dramatically. Before horses, hunting bison on foot required patience, planning, and great cooperation. Hunters might disguise themselves under wolfskins and creep close to a herd, they might surround a group of animals and drive them into a corral built of brush and logs, or they might guide a herd toward a cliff, using lines of stones and people waving robes to steer the animals in the right direction.
84:17
One of the most famous sites of this kind, in what is now Alberta, was used for some 6,000 years.
84:23
These methods worked, but they depended on luck, terrain and the mood of the bison, which was not always cooperative. On horseback, a hunter could ride right alongside a running herd, choose a particular animal and bring it down with arrows or a lance at close range. A good hunter on a good horse could take several bison in a single chase.
84:44
The most valuable horses of all were specially trained buffalo runners, fast, brave and steady animals that could be guided with the knees alone, leaving the rider's hands free. A great buffalo runner was worth a fortune, and its owner took better care of it than of almost anything else he owned. If you think people today are protective of their cars, imagine a car that could also find dinner for you. Riding itself had to be adapted to the new world. Plains peoples did not simply copy the heavy Spanish saddle with its iron fittings, they developed their own equipment out of the materials they had at hand.
85:17
Men often rode with a light pad saddle, little more than a stuffed piece of hide, or with no saddle at all. Women, who did much of the work of moving camp, used high saddles with tall wooden frames in front and behind, sturdy enough to carry children, baggage, and household goods on long journeys.
85:34
Bridles were often just a single cord looped around the horse's lower jaw. Many riders painted their horses for war or for ceremonies, with symbols that recorded the rider's deeds or called on protective powers, and they decorated bridles, saddles and blankets with quillwork and beads.
85:50
A well-dressed horse was a statement, much like a well-dressed rider. Some peoples went further and became serious breeders. The most famous example comes from the Plateau region, west of the Rocky Mountains, where the Nez Perce built up large herds and selected their horses carefully for strength, speed and endurance. they became known for horses with distinctive spotted coats, the ancestors of the breed now called the Appaloosa. While European aristocrats were boasting about their stables, the Nez Perce were quietly running one of the most successful horse breeding programs on the continent.
86:23
While horses were spreading north from the Spanish southwest, a second revolution was moving across the continent in the opposite direction. It came from the northeast, and it was made of iron and gunpowder. As we saw with the beaver trade around the Great Lakes, European traders were eager to exchange firearms for furs. In 1670, the English founded the Hudson's Bay Company, which built trading posts on the shores of Hudson Bay, far to the north.
86:49
Meanwhile, French traders, many of them independent adventurers known as coureurs de bois, which means runners of the woods, travelled deep into the Great Lakes and beyond, paddling canoes loaded with goods to exchange for pelts.
87:01
Both British and French traders sold guns, powder and lead to their native partners, especially to peoples like the Cree and the Assiniboine, who became powerful middlemen in the fur trade. Here is the interesting part. The Spanish, as we have seen, were generally determined not to sell guns to native peoples. They had learned, at great cost, how dangerous that could be. The French and British competing fiercely with each other for furs were far less careful, so for decades the continent was divided in a strange way. In the southwest, peoples had horses but few guns.
87:33
In the northeast, peoples had guns but few horses. And somewhere in the middle of the Great Plains in the 1730s through the 1750s, these two waves met. We have a rare, vivid account of what that meeting looked like.
87:46
In the winter of 1787 to 1788, a young fur trader and mapmaker named David Thompson spent several months living with a band of Pikani, one of the peoples of the Blackfoot Confederacy.
87:57
There he met an elderly man named Sulkamapi, who had been born among the Cree but had lived with the Pikani for most of his life. Over many long winter evenings, Sulkamapi told Thompson stories of his youth, and Thompson wrote them down.
88:10
Sulkamapi remembered a time when the Pikani's great enemies were the Shoshone, who lived to the south and west. The Shoshone had acquired horses before the Pikani did and they used them to devastating effect, riding into Pikani camps, striking quickly and racing away before anyone could respond.
88:28
Some Shoshone riders even wore armour made of layered leather, The Pekani, fighting on foot, had a very difficult time. Then the balance shifted. Through their Cree and Assiniboine allies, the Pekani obtained a small number of guns. Sokamapi described a battle in which his side, with just a handful of firearms, met a large Shoshone force.
88:49
When the guns were fired, the Shoshone, who had never faced such weapons, were shocked by the noise and the effect, and their lines broke.
88:57
Leather armour, it turned out, was not much use against musket balls. Saikamapi also remembered the first time his people saw a horse up close. It was a dead horse, left behind after an encounter with the Shoshone, and everyone gathered around to look at it in wonder. They did not know what to call it, so they compared it to the animals they knew. It was as big as an elk, but it carried burdens like a dog, so it became the elk dog.
89:22
Within a few years the Pekani had horses of their own and they too became mounted warriors.
89:28
In one man's lifetime his people had gone from walking to riding and from stone weapons to firearms.
89:34
Most of us struggle to adjust when our phone updates its software. The combination of horses and guns was enormously powerful, but it was not as simple as it might sound. the muskets of the 18th century were slow to reload, heavy and not very accurate. Trying to reload one while galloping on horseback was nearly impossible. For hunting bison on horseback, the bow and arrow actually remained the superior weapon for a long time because a skilled rider could shoot many arrows in the time it took to reload a single musket.
90:03
guns were most valuable in other situations in pitched battles in defending camps and in breaking enemy charges so the most successful plains peoples did not simply replace one weapon with another they used both choosing the right tool for the job the meeting point of the two revolutions also created a fascinating trade network along the upper missouri river in what is now north dakota stood the large permanent earth lodge villages of the mandan and the hidatsa These were farming peoples who grew corn, beans and squash, much like the Haudenosaunee in the east.
90:36
Their villages became one of the great trading hubs of the continent. Horses arrived there from the southwest, brought by peoples like the Crow and the Cheyenne. Guns, metal goods and cloth arrived from the northeast, brought by the Cree, the Assiniboine and European traders. The Mandan and Hidatsa sat right in the middle, trading corn, buying horses, selling guns and taking a profit at every step. In a sense, they were running the biggest marketplace on the Great Plains. Other farming peoples along the Missouri, such as the Araucara, played a similar role.
91:08
Their villages were large, well-defended, and prosperous. And that prosperity, unfortunately, made them especially vulnerable to what came next. In 1779, smallpox broke out in Mexico City.
91:21
Over the following three years it spread along the trade routes that connected the continent, moving north with traders, travellers and raiders.
91:29
By 1780 and 1781 it had reached the Great Plains and from there it continued all the way north to the Hudson Bay region and beyond. It was one of the most devastating epidemics in the history of North America. There are no precise figures, but some peoples may have lost half or more of their population within a single year. The epidemic did not strike everyone equally. It hit hardest in places where many people lived close together, which meant the large permanent villages of the farming peoples along the Missouri.
91:58
The Arikara, who may once have lived in dozens of villages, were reduced to just a few. The Mandan, who had lived in several thriving towns, had to consolidate into two. The Hidatsa also suffered terrible losses. Nomadic peoples were hit hard as well, but because they lived in smaller groups that moved frequently, they had a better chance of escaping the full force of the disease.
92:20
The consequences were far-reaching. The great farming villages of the Missouri had been powerful barriers that controlled the river crossings and the trade routes.
92:28
Now they were weakened and unable to resist pressure from their neighbours. The mounted nomadic peoples, who were growing stronger every year thanks to their horses and guns, found the way open.
92:38
As we will see in the story of the Sioux, the weakening of the Arikara in particular cleared a path toward the west. In the cruel arithmetic of history, one people's catastrophe became another people's opportunity. With the horse came new ideas about wealth. Before horses, the plains had been a fairly equal place. Everyone owned roughly the same things, because everyone could only carry roughly the same things. Now people could own horses, and horses were valuable, portable, and could multiply. A family needed a decent number of horses to move camp, carry its teepee, hunt and travel.
93:13
A wealthy man might own dozens or even hundreds. A poor family might have only a few or have to borrow from relatives. For the first time there was a visible gap between rich and poor on the plains and you could tell how rich someone was simply by looking at the size of the herd grazing near their teepee.
93:29
It was the 18th century version of checking out the neighbour's driveway. Horses became the main currency of social life. A young man who wanted to marry often offered horses to the family of his intended bride. A leader who wanted to show generosity gave horses away, and generosity was one of the most admired qualities a person could have. In fact, among many Plains peoples, the more you gave away, the higher your status climbed. Wealth was not about keeping things, it was about having enough to share. Imagine a world where the most respected person in town is not the one with the biggest house, but the one who keeps giving away their cars.
94:04
Naturally, this also made horses the main prize in conflicts between peoples. Raiding an enemy camp to take horses became one of the most important ways for a young man to prove himself. Sneaking into an enemy camp at night and leading away a prized horse that its owner had tied right next to his teepee was considered an outstanding achievement, far more impressive than simply grabbing a few animals from a loosely guarded herd. In fact, the whole idea of bravery on the plains was often focused less on killing enemies than on daring and skill.
94:34
Many peoples practiced what is known as counting coup. The greatest honor was not to kill an enemy, but to ride up close and touch him with your hand or with a special stick and then get away unharmed. It showed that you were brave enough to come within reach and skilled enough to escape. These deeds were recorded, recounted at gatherings, and displayed in symbols painted on teepees, robes, and shields. The Plains Warriors' resume, you could say, was worn in public, The horse revolution also transformed the lives of women, though not always in ways that made life easier.
95:06
With horses, men could hunt far more bison than before, but every bison that was brought down had to be processed, the meat cut and dried, the hide scraped, tanned and softened, a slow and exhausting task that fell mostly to women.
95:20
As the trade in buffalo robes with Europeans grew, the demand for tanned hides soared. A skilled hunter could now bring in more hides than one woman could possibly process.
95:31
One consequence was that in many plain societies it became more common for a successful man to have more than one wife, because his household needed more hands to keep up with the work.
95:41
That was not exactly a step forward for gender equality. At the same time, women held important forms of authority. In many plain societies, the tipi belonged to the woman who made it and set it up, and she decided where it would stand in the camp.
95:55
Women owned horses of their own, managed the family's property, and decorated clothing, bags and tipis with quill work and later with glass beads, creating art that was highly valued and traded widely.
96:07
The work of a talented quill worker was a source of real prestige, So women's lives became busier and harder, but they also remained central to the wealth, the art and the daily functioning of the community. The horse also forced people to rethink where and how they lived. Horses needed grass and water, and lots of both. A big herd could strip the land around a camp in a matter of days, which meant camps had to move more often.
96:33
In winter, when grass was scarce, people sheltered in river valleys, where cottonwood trees provided firewood and where the inner bark of the trees could be fed to the horses.
96:42
Managing a herd became a full-time job and young boys spent much of their time watching over the family's horses, which also turned them into expert riders from a very early age. Finally, the horse pulled entire peoples onto the plains who had never lived there before. The Cheyenne, for example, had been farmers living in earth lodge villages in the region of Minnesota and the Dakotas. Over the 18th century, they gradually abandoned farming and became mounted bison hunters. The crow separated from the Hidatsa and moved west into the country of the Yellowstone River.
97:14
The Kiowa moved south from the mountains. The plains became a magnet, attracting peoples from the forests, the mountains, the river valleys and the deserts, all eager to take part in the new way of life. And this is perhaps the most surprising lesson of the whole story. The world that most of us picture when we think of native North America, the feathered riders racing across the grass after bison, with painted teepees in the background, was not an ancient, timeless tradition. It was, in historical terms, quite new.
97:42
it emerged in the 18th century and reached its height in the first half of the 19th from the arrival of the horse to the destruction of the great bison herds the classic horse culture of the plains lasted perhaps a century and a half that is less time than separates us today from the american civil war it was a brilliant creative and incredibly dynamic way of life and it was born out of revolution and change not out of a frozen past two peoples in particular rode this new wave further than anyone else In the north, a group of former forest dwellers from the lakes of Minnesota would turn the horse into the foundation of a great power.
98:18
But first let's go south, to a people who were among the very first to master the horse and who used it to build something that historians now dare to call an empire. The people who would build that empire called themselves Numunu, which simply means the people. As we saw earlier, their language is so close to Shoshone that speakers of the two can largely understand each other, and that is because, around the year 1700, the Numunu were a branch of the Shoshone. They lived in the high country of what is now Wyoming and the surrounding region, a land of mountains, sagebrush, and long, hard winters.
98:52
Life there was demanding. They hunted when they could, gathered roots and seeds, and moved with the seasons. They were tough, skilled, and resourceful, but nobody would have described them as a great power. At this point, their main concern was getting through the next winter, not conquering anybody.
99:10
Then two things happened at roughly the same time. The first was the arrival of the horse, spreading north from New Mexico through the trade networks we followed in the last chapter. The second was a decision, or more likely a series of decisions by many families, to head south.
99:26
historians still debate exactly why some point to pressure from other peoples in the north others emphasize the pull of the south where there were warmer winters richer grasslands bigger bison herds and above all easier access to the horses and goods of the spanish colonies Whatever the reasons, the Numunu split away from the rest of the Shoshone and began moving south along the eastern edge of the Rocky Mountains. It was the beginning of one of the most dramatic transformations in the history of the continent.
99:55
The name by which the rest of the world came to know them, Comanche was not their own.
100:00
It most likely comes from the language of the Ute, their early allies, who called them by a word that is often translated as something like those who are always against us, or simply enemies.
100:10
The Spanish heard the word, turned it into Comanche, and the name stuck. So much like the Haudenosaunee, the Comanche ended up known to history by a label someone else gave them. In this case, the irony is that it was coined by their friends. With allies like that, who needs rivals?
100:28
The first time the name appears in a written record is in 1706. A Spanish officer in New Mexico returning from an expedition reported that the people of the Pueblo of Taos were worried. They had heard that Ute and Comanche raiders were planning an attack. With that simple note, the Comanche made their entrance into recorded history, and the Spanish of New Mexico had no idea how much time they would spend writing about them over the next century and a half. What set the Comanche apart from almost everyone else was how completely they embraced the horse. Many peoples of the plains became excellent riders.
100:59
The Comanche became something more. Children were placed on horses almost as soon as they could hold on. By the age of four or five, a boy would usually have his own pony and he would spend much of his childhood riding, racing and looking after the family herd. Girls rode well, too, and Comanche women were renowned horsewomen in their own right. Young riders practiced difficult skills over and over until they became second nature.
101:22
One classic exercise was to gallop at full speed, lean down, and scoop an object off the ground without slowing down.
101:30
Another, more serious version, involved two riders working as a pair to sweep up a fallen companion between them at a full gallop and carry him to safety. It is the kind of training that would make most modern riding instructors quietly faint. The most famous Comanche technique was a manoeuvre that astonished every outsider who saw it.
101:48
a rider would braid a loop of rawhide into the horse's mane. In the middle of a charge he could slip his arm through the loop and drop down along the side of the galloping horse hooking one heel over its back. In that position his entire body was shielded by the horse and he could shoot arrows from under the horse's neck while riding at full speed. To an opponent it looked as if a riderless horse was charging toward them while arrows flew out of nowhere. It was spectacular, terrifying and extremely effective.
102:18
In 1834, the American painter George Catlin travelled onto the Southern Plains and spent time with the Comanche. He painted them, sketched them and wrote down his impressions. He noted, with a certain honesty, that Comanche men on foot did not look especially graceful. They were, as he put it in his own words, rather slow and awkward when walking.
102:39
But the moment they mounted a horse, he wrote, they were transformed, and he described them as the most extraordinary horsemen he had ever seen.
102:47
It is one of the more charming compliments in the history of ethnography, more or less saying that these were people who looked a little clumsy until you gave them a horse, and then they became the best riders on earth.
102:58
The Comanche did not just ride horses, they collected them on a massive scale. A successful Comanche family could own hundreds of horses and a few exceptional individuals were said to own more than a thousand.
103:10
Across the whole Comanche world, the total number of horses ran into the tens of thousands, possibly far more, making them one of the greatest horse-owning peoples on the continent. They bred horses, captured wild mustangs, took them in raids and traded them to other peoples. In fact, horse trading became one of the foundations of their economy. The Comanche were not only riders and warriors, they were also in a sense the biggest horse dealers on the southern plains.
103:37
With this mounted power, the Comanche moved south and east and they collided with the people who had dominated the southern plains before them, the Apache.
103:46
In the early 18th century, several Apache groups lived on the plains of what is now eastern Colorado, western Kansas and the Texas Panhandle. They hunted bison, but many of them also farmed small plots along rivers and streams, growing corn and squash. That turned out to be a serious weakness. Farming people have to stay near their fields and fields cannot run away. The Comanche, by contrast, were fully mobile. They could strike wherever they chose and vanish again across the grasslands. Over the course of several decades, the Comanche, at first allied with the Ute, pushed the Apache steadily off the southern plains.
104:21
By the middle of the 18th century, Apache groups such as the Lipan had been driven south into central and southern Texas, while others retreated to the mountains of New Mexico.
104:30
The southern plains now belonged to the Comanche. The vast territory they came to control became known as Comancheria. It stretched across much of what is now western Texas, western Oklahoma, eastern New Mexico, southeastern Colorado, and southwestern Kansas.
104:47
At its height, it covered an area larger than many European countries put together, a sea of grassland, river valleys, canyons and high plateaus, and it was home to the Comanche nation, which by some estimates may have grown to as many as 40,000 people in the late 18th century, along with enormous herds of horses and the great southern bison herds.
105:10
For a long time, historians described the Comanche mainly as fearsome raiders on the margins of the Spanish and Mexican frontier.
105:18
Then, in 2008, a historian from Finland, a country better known for saunas and long winters than for studies of the Texas plains, published a book that changed the conversation. His name is Pekka Hamelainen, and the book was called The Comanche Empire.
105:33
It won some of the most important awards in American history writing, and it made a bold argument.
105:39
According to Himalayanan, the Comanche were not simply a people resisting colonial expansion. For about a century, they were the dominant power in the region, an empire in their own right, and it was the Spanish and later the Mexicans who lived on the margins of their world rather than the other way around.
105:55
Now, this was not an empire in the European sense. There was no emperor, no capital city, no palace, no standing army and no tax office. Nobody would have recognised it as an empire by looking at a map in Madrid. But Heimelainen argued that it worked like one in practice. The Comanche controlled the main trade routes of the southern plains. They decided who could trade with whom and on what terms. They extracted goods from the Spanish colonies through a mix of trade, raiding and diplomacy. Spanish officials learned that the best way to avoid raids was to keep the Comanche happy with regular gifts of manufactured goods, tobacco, cloth and metal tools.
106:35
On paper, these were presents. In practice, they looked a lot like tribute. Imagine being a colonial governor and having to set aside a part of your budget each year for gifts to the neighbours, just so they would kindly not come to visit.
106:49
The Comanche also built a large commercial network. At the trade fairs of New Mexico, they exchanged buffalo hides, meat and horses for corn, bread, metal goods and other products. Traders from New Mexico, known as Comancheros, ventured out onto the plains to do business directly with the Comanche, sometimes in places that were far beyond any Spanish authority. Comanche horses and mules flowed north and east to other native peoples, and later to American traders.
107:17
And captives, taken in raids on Spanish settlements and on other native peoples, were part of this world too. Some were traded or ransomed back. Many were adopted into Comanche families and eventually became Comanche themselves.
107:31
Like the Haudenosaunee in the northeast, the Comanche grew in part by absorbing outsiders and over time a significant number of people living in Comancheria had been born somewhere else. The Spanish, unsurprisingly, did not enjoy being on the receiving end of this system and in the 1750s they tried to push back. As we just saw, the Lipan Apache had been driven into Texas by the Comanche and they asked the Spanish for help. The Spanish saw a chance. If they could convert the Apache and settle them in missions, they would gain a buffer against the Comanche.
108:02
So in 1757, they built a mission called Santa Cruz de San Sabar on the San Sabar River in central Texas, along with a small military post nearby.
108:11
There was only one problem. The Apache themselves never really settled there. They visited, accepted gifts and moved on. They seemed to have understood something the Spanish did not, that building a mission for Apaches in the middle of territory, the Comanche considered theirs was a very effective way of attracting the Comanche.
108:29
In March of 1758, that is exactly what happened.
108:34
A large force of Comanche warriors and their allies, including Wichita and other peoples, arrived at the mission, perhaps around 2,000 in all.
108:42
Many of them carried French firearms obtained through trade networks to the east.
108:47
The Spanish soldiers at the nearby post were few and the mission was quickly overwhelmed. It was burned to the ground and among those who died were two of the priests. For Spain, it was a shocking defeat.
109:00
It was the first time a Spanish mission in Texas had been destroyed in this way, and it showed just how badly the Spanish had underestimated the power of the Comanche and their allies.
109:10
The Spanish organized a punishing response. In 1759, an expedition of several hundred soldiers and allies marched north under Colonel Diego Ortiz Parilla.
109:20
They followed the trail all the way to the Red River, where they found a large fortified village of the Wichita, with a stockade, a moat and many Comanche allies inside.
109:30
According to Spanish accounts, there was even a French flag flying over the fort. The Spanish attacked and the attack did not go well.
109:38
After a fierce fight, Perilla's force retreated, leaving behind two of its cannons.
109:44
If the destruction of Sansa Bar had been a shock, this was an embarrassment and the Spanish frontier in Texas spent the next several decades very much on the defensive. In New Mexico, meanwhile, relations with the Comanche swung back and forth between trade and conflict.
109:59
In the 1770s, one Comanche war leader in particular became the terror of the province. The Spanish called him Cuerno Verde, which means greenhorn, after the distinctive headdress he wore, which had a single horn painted green. According to Spanish sources, his father had been killed in an earlier clash with the Spanish, and Cuerno Verde had made it his personal mission to avenge him. His raids struck settlements across New Mexico, and the colony seemed powerless to stop him. That changed with the arrival of a new governor, Juan Bautista de Anza.
110:31
Anza was an experienced frontier officer who had already made a name for himself by leading an expedition overland to California and helping to found the settlement that would become San Francisco.
110:42
In 1779 he gathered several hundred soldiers and militiamen, along with Ute and Jicarilla Apache allies who had their own reasons to oppose the Comanche and marched north.
110:53
Instead of following the usual route onto the plains, he took a less expected path through the mountains and the San Luis Valley, approaching Comanche territory from the north. It worked.
111:03
Near the present-day city of Pueblo, Colorado, his force caught up with Cuerno Verde, who was returning from a raid. In the battle that followed, Cuerno Verde was killed, along with his eldest son and several other leaders. A mountain in southern Colorado, Greenhorn Mountain, still carries his name today.
111:22
But Anza understood something important. A military victory alone would not solve the problem. The Comanche were far too numerous and too strong to be defeated outright, and continued war would only bleed the colony dry.
111:35
What New Mexico needed was a lasting peace, and for that the Spanish needed a Comanche leader who could speak for more than one band.
111:43
They found him in a man named Equeracarpa, which the Spanish translated as leather cape. He was a respected leader who worked hard to bring together several Comanche divisions behind a common agreement.
111:54
In 1786 at the Pueblo of Pecos, he and Anza concluded a peace treaty. Anza presented him with a ceremonial staff of office as a sign of his authority, and according to Spanish accounts the Comanche marked the occasion by digging a hole in the ground and then filling it in, burying the war, a gesture that the Haudenosaunee would surely have appreciated. The peace of 1786 turned out to be remarkably durable. It lasted for decades. The Comanche and the Spanish traded regularly, the Spanish continued to provide gifts, and Comanche and Spanish forces even campaigned together against their common Apache enemies.
112:31
New Mexico, which had been on the brink of collapse, began to grow and prosper again. A similar peace was reached with the Spanish in Texas around the same time. It is a reminder that the story of the Comanche is not only one of war. When it served their interests they were skilled diplomats and reliable partners. They simply expected the terms to be fair and the gifts to keep arriving on time. That arrangement began to fall apart in the early 19th century.
112:57
In 1821, Mexico won its independence from Spain.
113:01
The new Mexican government was poor, politically unstable, and preoccupied with its own conflicts. The gifts that had kept the peace became irregular and then mostly stopped.
113:11
Mexican troops on the northern frontier were badly paid and badly equipped. At the same time, a growing demand for horses and mules among American traders and settlers to the east made raiding more profitable than ever.
113:23
For the Comanche, the calculation was simple. If the gifts were no longer coming, they would collect the goods another way. What followed were some of the most far-reaching raids in the history of the continent.
113:34
From the 1830s through the 1840s, large Comanche war parties, often joined by their Kiowa allies, rode south across the Rio Grande and deep into northern Mexico. They struck the states of Chihuahua, Coahuila, Nuevo Leon, Durango, and Tamaulipas, and in some cases they reached as far as Zacatecas and San Luis Potosí, hundreds of kilometers into the Mexican interior. These expeditions could last for months. The raiders returned with enormous herds of horses and mules, along with captives and goods, which then flowed into the trade networks of the plains.
114:10
The well-worn routes they followed south became known as the Comanche Trail, and in places the paths were so heavily used that they could be seen from a great distance, worn into the land like highways.
114:22
The raids often took place in the autumn, when the weather was mild and the grass was still good, and they were often timed by the full moon, which gave enough light for riding and herding animals at night. Texans and Mexicans came to dread that bright autumn moon. They called it the Comanche moon. It must be one of the very few cases in history where a phase of the moon became a regional security warning.
114:44
The effect on northern Mexico was devastating. The historian Brian DeLay, in a book called War of a Thousand Deserts, has argued that these raids left large parts of the Mexican north depopulated, impoverished and exhausted, with ranches abandoned and towns living in fear.
115:00
And this happened just before the United States invaded Mexico in 1846. When American armies marched south, they found a region that had already been weakened by years of Comanche raids. In other words, the Comanche had a significant and often overlooked influence on the outcome of a war in which they did not officially take part History textbooks usually tell the story of the Mexican-American War as a conflict between two countries. The Comanche, it turns out, had been shaping that story for years in the background. Behind these long raids stood an important diplomatic shift on the plains themselves.
115:33
For decades, the Comanche had been at war with many of their neighbours, including the Kiowa, who lived to their north.
115:40
But around the beginning of the 19th century, the two peoples made peace, and the Kiowa, together with a small group of Plains Apache who lived with them, became the Comanche's closest allies.
115:50
Then, in 1840, came something even bigger.
115:54
Near the trading post known as Bent's Fort, on the Arkansas River in what is now Colorado, the Comanche, the Kiowa, and the Plains Apache met with their old enemies the Cheyenne and the Arapaho and concluded a great peace. It was celebrated with feasts and an enormous exchange of gifts. The Comanche and Kiowa, rich in horses, gave away so many animals that some Cheyenne reportedly did not have enough rope to lead them all home. It may be the only peace treaty in history where the main logistical problem was a shortage of rope.
116:22
With their northern border secure, the Comanche could focus their attention south, toward Texas and Mexico. The Comanche world was not only about war, trade and diplomacy, it also had a rich spiritual dimension. The Comanche believed in a sacred power they called Puha, a force that could be found in the natural world and acquired by individuals.
116:43
A young man usually sought Puha through a vision quest, going alone to an isolated place to fast and pray until a spirit, often in the form of an animal, appeared and offered him power and guidance. That power came with rules. A man might be told never to eat a certain food, or never to let anyone pass behind him while he was eating, and breaking those rules could make the power vanish. So a great Comanche warrior was not just a skilled rider and fighter. He was also someone who carefully kept a set of very personal instructions from the spirit world, a little like following a set of warranty conditions that came directly from the sky.
117:20
Comanche life on a daily basis was organised around the herd and the hunt. Men hunted bison, raided and cared for the horses, while women processed the meat and hides, made clothing and teepees, gathered plants and moved the camp. Comanche food was famously heavy on meat, and European visitors were often surprised by how little else people ate. Vegetables were a seasonal bonus rather than a regular part of the menu, which would have made any modern nutritionist slightly nervous. Corn and other farm products were mostly obtained through trade with farming peoples and New Mexican settlers, another reason why trade networks mattered so much to them.
117:56
The Texans, too, came to know the power of the Comanche all too well. The Republic of Texas, which broke away from Mexico in 1836, sat right on the edge of Comanchuria, and its relations with the Comanche were tense and often violent.
118:09
The raid on Linville that opened our story came straight out of this world. It was the answer of the Penetica Comanche to the disaster at the council house in San Antonio, where their leaders had been killed during peace talks.
118:21
As we saw at the start, the riders went all the way to the sea and the people of Linville watched their town burn from boats in the bay.
118:28
Few things expressed the reach of Comanche power more vividly than a war party from the southern plains looking out over the waters of the Gulf of Mexico.
118:37
To understand why the Comanche were such a formidable and frustrating opponent, we have to look at how their society was organised. The Comanche were never a single, centralised state. They were divided into a number of large divisions, which outsiders often called bands, and each of these divisions was itself made up of many smaller local groups.
118:56
The names of the divisions tell you something about their lives and territories. The Penateca, whose name is often translated as honey-eaters, lived in the south and east, closest to the settlements of Texas. The Cozzutica were the buffalo-eaters. The Amparica took their name from a type of edible root.
119:15
The Naconi were known as those who turned back, or wanderers. The Quahadi, sometimes translated as antelope people, lived out on the high, dry plains of the Llano Estacado in the far west of Texas, and they would become the most independent and the last to surrender. There were others as well, and the lines between them were not fixed. Families could move from one group to another, and new groups could form while old ones faded away.
119:40
Leadership was based on respect and persuasion, not on command. Each local group had a peace leader, usually an older man known for his wisdom and generosity, who guided daily life and tried to settle disputes.
119:53
War leaders were chosen for particular expeditions, based on their reputation and their record. Important decisions were discussed in councils, where everyone withstanding could speak.
120:04
No leader could force anyone to follow him. If a family disagreed with the decision, they could simply pack up their teepee, round up their horses and go somewhere else. It was a society with a very strong sense of personal freedom. Try to imagine a country where, if you did not like the government's policy, you could take your house and your car and simply relocate to a different government by the end of the week. This structure gave the Comanche enormous strengths. There was no capital that an enemy could capture, no king who could be forced to surrender, and no single army that could be destroyed in one decisive battle.
120:40
If one group was defeated, the others carried on. Raids could be launched by many different groups at once, from many different directions.
120:48
For the Spanish, the Mexicans and later the Texans and Americans, fighting the Comanche was like trying to catch water with your hands. But the same structure also created serious weaknesses, especially when it came to diplomacy. When a Spanish, Mexican or American official negotiated with a Comanche leader, he naturally assumed he was dealing with someone who spoke for the whole nation. In reality, that leader usually spoke only for his own group and perhaps for a few others who trusted him.
121:17
A treaty signed with the Penetica did not bind the Quahadi. A promise made by one peace leader did not stop a young war leader from another group from organising a raid of his own. To the colonial powers this often looked like treachery. To the Comanche it was simply how their society worked. Neither side fully understood the other and that misunderstanding fed a long cycle of broken agreements, angry accusations and renewed violence. Equera Capa's achievement in 1786 was so remarkable precisely because it was the exception, a moment when several divisions agreed to act together.
121:52
Most of the time that kind of unity was very hard to achieve. It would make the Comanche extraordinarily hard to defeat on the battlefield and extraordinarily difficult to protect at the negotiating table, a double-edged sword that would matter enormously in the decades to come. By the middle of the 19th century the Comanche stood at the height of their power. They ruled the southern plains, they had pushed the Apache aside, they had held Spain to a respectful peace, and they had helped to drain the strength of northern Mexico. Their horses grazed across a territory larger than most European kingdoms, and their name was known and feared from Santa Fe to the Gulf of Mexico.
122:29
Far to the north, meanwhile, another people was rising on the same wave of horses and bison.
122:34
They had started their journey not in the mountains, but among the lakes and forests of the upper Mississippi, and their path onto the plains had begun, oddly enough, as a retreat.
122:44
The people the world knows as the Sioux call themselves the Osseti Sakowin, which means the Seven Council Fires.
122:51
The name reflects an alliance of seven related groups who considered themselves one people, bound together by language, kinship and shared ceremonies. In the old days, the seven would gather from time to time, each with its own council fire to discuss common matters, renew ties and celebrate together. The word Sioux, on the other hand, is another one of those names bestowed by outsiders. It comes from the French, who shortened a term they had picked up from the Ojibwe or another neighboring Algonquian people, and its original meaning is usually translated as something like little snakes or enemies.
123:23
As you may have noticed by now, being named by your neighbours was practically a tradition in North America, and the neighbours were rarely in a complimentary mood. The seven council fires fall into three large branches, and they are usually known by the three forms of their language. In the east were four groups who called themselves Dakota. The French often called them the Santee. In the middle were two groups known as the Yankton and Yanktoni, who are often grouped under the name Nakota, although the details of that label are debated. and in the West was the single largest group, the Teton, who call themselves Lakota.
123:57
The three forms of the language are closely related and one of the most famous differences between them is surprisingly simple. Many words that use the sound L in Lakota use D in Dakota and N in Nakota, so the word for friend is Kola in Lakota, Koda in Dakota and Kona in Nakota. It is a bit like three cousins pronouncing the same word in three different ways and each insisting that the others have a funny accent. The Lakota, the westernmost branch and the one that will become the most famous, were themselves divided into seven groups. The Oglala, the Sikangu, also known by the French name Brule, the Hunkpapa, the Mnikonju, the Sihasapa, the Itasipko and the Uhenumpa.
124:38
If that sounds like a lot of names to keep track of, do not worry. The important thing to remember is that the Lakota had their own internal structure, and much like the Comanche, they did not have a single ruler. Each group and each smaller community within it made its own decisions.
124:55
In the 17th century, as we saw earlier, the ancestors of all these groups lived far from the open plains in the forests and lake country of what is now Minnesota and northwestern Wisconsin.
125:06
One of their most important centres was around Miller Lacks, a large lake in central Minnesota, a region of woods, marshes and countless smaller lakes.
125:16
Life there followed the rhythm of the seasons. In spring, people tapped maple trees and boiled down the sap to make sugar. In summer, they fished, gathered berries and planted small gardens. In autumn, they harvested wild rice, gliding through the shallow lakes in canoes and gently knocking the ripe grains off the stalks into the bottom of the boat.
125:36
In winter, they hunted deer, elk and bear in the forests. They also travelled west to the edge of the prairie to hunt bison on foot, but the prairie was a place they visited, not a place they called home.
125:48
The first Europeans to describe the Dakota in this world were French.
125:52
Around 1660, the traders Pierre Esprit Radisson and Medard-Choir de Grossellier made their way west of the Great Lakes and met Dakota communities.
126:02
A couple of decades later, in 1680, a French missionary named Louis Hennepin had a far more memorable introduction. While exploring the upper Mississippi, Hennepin and his two companions were taken captive by a Dakota war party and brought back to the villages around Mille Lacs.
126:18
He spent several months living among the Dakota, mostly as a sort of reluctant guest whose hosts were not entirely sure what to do with him. During his travels with them, he saw and named the great waterfall on the Mississippi that he called the Falls of St. Anthony, which today sits in the heart of the city of Minneapolis. Eventually another French explorer, Daniel Gré-Sillon, Sieur de Loup, arrived in the area and arranged his release. Hennepin went home to France and wrote a best-selling book about his adventures. In a later edition, he claimed to have travelled all the way down the Mississippi to the Gulf of Mexico, a journey that he almost certainly never made.
126:54
It seems that even in the 17th century, travel writers were not above adding a little extra excitement to their stories. The city of Duluth in Minnesota, meanwhile, carries the name of the man who rescued him, which is a fair reward for doing the actual work.
127:07
The Dakota's main neighbours to the east and north were the Ojibwe, an Algonquian speaking people who lived along the shores of the Great Lakes. As the fur trade expanded westward, the Ojibwe became important partners of the French, and that gave them earlier access to European goods, especially guns.
127:25
For a while, the two peoples found a way to profit from each other. In 1679, Duluth helped broker an agreement under which the Ojibwe acted as middlemen, carrying French goods to the Dakota in exchange for access to Dakota hunting grounds.
127:39
It was a sensible arrangement that brought decades of relative peace.
127:43
But in the 1730s that peace broke down and a long and bitter conflict followed. The Ojibwe, well-armed and steadily moving westward, pushed into the late country of Minnesota. According to tradition, by around the middle of the 18th century the Dakota had been forced to leave their old centres around Millilax.
128:01
Now, if you only looked at the map at this moment, you might conclude that the Sioux were on the losing side of history, a people being pushed out of their homeland by a better-armed neighbour. And for the Dakota who stayed in the woodlands and river valleys of southern Minnesota, life did become more constrained. But for others, especially the Lakota, what looked like a retreat turned into one of the most remarkable expansions in the history of North America. because as they moved west, they were moving toward two things that would change everything for them. Millions of bison and the horse.
128:33
The Lakota began to acquire horses around the middle of the 18th century, somewhat later than the Comanche and the peoples of the Southern Plains. They obtained them through trade, through raids, and through contact with neighbours such as the Cheyenne and the farming peoples along the Missouri River. With horses, the Lakota could finally leave the forest edge behind and follow the herds deep into the open grasslands. And as they went west, they ran into the same barrier we described earlier, the large and well-defended earth lodge villages of the Arikara along the Missouri.
129:04
For a time, the Arikara controlled the river crossings and stood in the Lakota's path. But as we saw, smallpox had devastated those villages and the Arikara were severely weakened. By the end of the 18th century, Lakota groups had crossed the Missouri and pushed into the lands beyond, into what is now western South Dakota, eastern Wyoming and Montana.
129:26
The Dakota stayed largely in the east, and the Yankton and Yanktonai settled into the prairies in between, but the Lakota became the great western branch of the Ositi Sakowin.
129:36
How do we know the timing of these events? Part of the answer comes from a remarkable Lakota tradition, the winter count. A winter count is a calendar, painted on a buffalo hide or later on cloth or paper. Each year is represented by a single picture, an image of the most memorable event of that year.
129:54
The year was counted from one first snowfall to the next, which is why the record is called a winter count. So instead of saying that something happened in a particular numbered year, a Lakota keeper of the count might say it happened in the winter when many horses were captured, or the winter when the people had a great sickness.
130:12
The pictures were arranged in a spiral or in rows and the keeper of the count was responsible for adding a new image each year and for remembering and explaining all the earlier ones. It was a history book, a calendar and a memory aid all rolled into one and it was maintained over generations. Some of these winter counts survive today and they give historians a precious window into the Lakota past.
130:34
One famous example records a spectacular meteor shower in November 1833 when the skies over North America filled with shooting stars. The winter count shows it as the winter when the stars fell. It is a wonderful example of how carefully the keepers observed the world. Even the Lakota astronomers, so to speak, were on the job, and one of the most important entries in several winter counts relates to the year around 1775 to 1776.
131:01
According to the winter count kept by an Oglala leader known as American Horse, that was the winter when a man named Standing Bull discovered the Black Hills, and he brought back a pine tree from those mountains as proof.
131:13
The Black Hills, known in Lakota as Paha Sapa, rise from the plains of western South Dakota and northeastern Wyoming, like an island of dark forested peaks in a sea of grass. Seen from a distance, the pine trees make them look almost black, which is where the name comes from. At the time the Lakota arrived, the region was home to other peoples, including the Kiowa and the Cheyenne, and the Crow also had strong ties to it. Over the following decades, the Lakota pushed them out and made the Black Hills their own. In time, the Black Hills became far more than just good hunting country, with shelter from winter storms and plenty of wood and water.
131:50
They became a sacred landscape at the heart of Lakota spiritual life, a place connected to origins, ceremonies and prayer.
131:57
Many Lakota today describe the Black Hills as the heart of everything that is.
132:02
That bond would later place the hills at the very centre of the most important conflict between the Lakota and the United States. But that is a story for later in our journey. On the plains, the life of the Lakota was built around the Bison. And when I say built around, I mean that almost literally.
132:19
Bison meat was the main food, eaten fresh after a hunt or cut into thin strips and dried in the sun to make jerky that could last for months. Dried meat was also pounded together with fat and dried berries to make pemmican, a dense, long-lasting, high-energy food that could keep a person going on long journeys. You could call it the original energy bar, although it probably did not come with a list of ingredients on the wrapper. But food was only the beginning.
132:44
Bison hides, scraped, tanned and softened, became the covers of teepees, as well as robes, blankets, clothing, moccasins, bags and shields.
132:55
Interestingly, the tanning process often used the animal's own brains, which contained natural oils that helped soften the hide. Bison bones became tools, scrapers, needles and knives. Horns were carved into spoons, cups and ladles. Sinew, the tough tendons along the spine, was dried and split into strong thread for sewing and for bowstrings. The stomach and the bladder became water containers and cooking vessels. Hooves were boiled down to make glue, the tail could serve as a flyswatter or a decoration, and the dried dung, known as buffalo chips, made excellent fuel on the treeless plains, which was very important in a landscape where firewood was sometimes harder to find than a decent cup of coffee.
133:36
Of course, collecting buffalo chips for the evening fire was probably not the most glamorous job in the camp, but somebody had to do it.
133:43
The tippy itself was a masterpiece of design. A typical Lakota tippy was made from somewhere between 10 and 20 bison hides, carefully cut and sewn together and stretched over a framework of long, slender poles, often made from lodgepole pine. It could be put up or taken down in a short time and it was carried from camp to camp by horses.
134:03
Inside, a fire in the centre kept it warm in winter, while smoke flaps at the top could be adjusted to the direction of the wind. In summer, the bottom edge of the cover could be rolled up to let in a cool breeze. The entrance usually faced east toward the rising sun.
134:18
Among the Lakota, the tipi belonged to the woman of the household, who made it, set it up, and decided where it would stand in the camp. When a large group gathered, the tipis were arranged in a great circle, each band and family in its traditional place. It was a portable city with a very clear seating plan. The basic building block of Lakota society was not the individual, and not even the single household, but the teospaye, an extended family group made up of several related households that lived and travelled together. A teospeia might include grandparents, parents, children, aunts, uncles, cousins, and in-laws, sometimes adding up to a few dozen tipis.
134:57
These were the people you hunted with, camped with, raised children with, and relied on in hard times.
135:04
Lakota kinship rules were broad and generous. Your father's brothers were also considered your fathers, and your mother's sisters were also your mothers, and their children were your brothers and sisters rather than your cousins. So a Lakota child could easily grow up with half a dozen fathers and mothers keeping an eye on them, which was wonderful for support and probably terrible for getting away with anything. Of course, a society with no single ruler still needed some way to keep order, especially during the most important event of the year, the communal bison hunt.
135:34
A large hunt required perfect coordination. If one impatient young man charged the herd too early, the bison would scatter and the whole camp might go hungry. So during the hunt, authority passed to men known as Akichita, often translated as camp police. They were chosen from respected warrior societies, and their job was to make sure everyone moved together and nobody broke ranks. Their powers were real. A hunter who ignored their orders and spoiled the hunt could have his weapons broken, his belongings destroyed, or even his teepee cut to pieces.
136:07
Then, once he had shown he understood the lesson, the community would often help him replace what he had lost.
136:13
It was a remarkably balanced system, strict punishment followed by forgiveness, and it kept the hunt and the camp running smoothly.
136:21
Men's lives were also shaped by the warrior societies, organisations that brought together men of different families around shared duties, songs, dances and codes of conduct. Each society had its own regalia and its own traditions, and membership was a mark of standing.
136:37
Some societies took on the role of akichita during hunts and camp moves, while others were known for particular kinds of bravery. Belonging to one was a bit like belonging to a combination of a sports club, a fraternity and a volunteer emergency service, with considerably more feathers involved.
136:54
The spiritual world of the Lakota was deep and complex. At its centre was the idea of wakan tanka, often translated as the great mystery or the great spirit. It is not exactly a single god in the way many Europeans imagined.
137:08
It is better understood as the sum of all the sacred, mysterious powers in the universe, the force present in the sun, the sky, the earth, the winds, the animals, and the people. The word wakan itself means sacred, holy, or mysterious. Everything in the world was seen as connected, and many Lakota prayers end with a phrase that expresses this idea beautifully, mitakuye oyasin, which means all my relatives. It refers not only to family, but to all people, all animals, all plants, and the earth itself.
137:40
Like the Comanche-seeking puha, a Lakota person could seek a personal connection with these powers through a vision quest, which the Lakota call Hamblatea, crying for a vision.
137:51
What made the Lakota version distinctive was the role of the community around it. The seeker first purified himself in the sweat lodge, a small dome of bent willow branches covered with hides, where water was poured over heated stones to fill the space with steam and prayer. A wikasa wakan, a holy man, prepared him, chose the place on the hilltop and afterward listened to the account of what he had seen and helped him understand it.
138:15
The vision did not belong only to the seeker. It could give him songs, protective designs for his shield, and a sense of purpose that his whole teospe would recognize. Spending days alone on a windy hilltop with an empty stomach is not most people's idea of personal development. but for the Lakota it was one of the most profound experiences of life. One of the most important ceremonies of the Lakota was the Sundance. It was held in summer when the bands came together after the long winter. A sacred cottonwood tree was chosen, cut down with great ceremony and raised in the centre of a specially prepared circle.
138:50
Over several days, dancers fasted, prayed and danced around the tree, gazing toward the sun and offering their suffering and endurance for the well-being of their families and the whole people. Some dancers fulfilled personal vows through acts of physical sacrifice, which made a powerful impression on outside observers. To the Lakota, the meaning was clear. It was a way of giving something of yourself, the only thing truly yours to give in return for the blessings of life.
139:16
The Sundance was also a great social event, a time when people reunited with relatives from other bands, arranged marriages, exchanged news and renewed the bonds that held the nation together. You could think of it as a religious ceremony, a family reunion and a national assembly all at once.
139:34
At the heart of Lakota religious life lay a sacred story about how their most important rituals came to them. Long ago, the story says, at a time when the people were hungry, two young scouts went out to look for bison. Instead, they saw a beautiful woman dressed in white walking toward them across the plains.
139:51
One of the scouts had disrespectful thoughts about her. A cloud descended over him, and when it lifted nothing was left of him but bones. That is one of history's most efficient lessons in good manners. The other scout, who had recognized that she was sacred, was told to return to his camp and prepare for her arrival. When she came to the camp, she brought a sacred pipe, the Chanunpa, and taught the people how to use it in prayer.
140:16
The smoke from the pipe, she explained, would carry their prayers upward to Wakantanka. She also taught them the seven sacred rites that would guide their spiritual life. Then she walked away from the camp and as the people watched she turned into a buffalo calf – first a reddish one, then a white one, then a black one – before disappearing over the hills. She became known as the White Buffalo Calf Woman. To this day the birth of a white buffalo calf is considered a sacred event of great significance by many Lakota and other Plains peoples. According to tradition, the original pipe she brought is still kept by a designated keeper among the Lakota, passed down through generations of the same family.
140:54
It is one of the most remarkable chains of spiritual custody anywhere in the world.
141:00
By the beginning of the 19th century, the Lakota had become the dominant power on the Northern Plains. They controlled a vast territory stretching from the Missouri River west to the Black Hills and beyond, into the country of the Powder River in what is now Wyoming and Montana. They were numerous, well-mounted, well-armed, and confident. They formed close alliances with two other peoples who had also embraced the horse and the bison, the Cheyenne and the Arapaho, and together these three nations became a formidable bloc.
141:29
Their main rivals included the Crow to the west, the Pawnee to the south, and the Shoshone in the mountains, along with their old adversaries the Ojibwe back in the east.
141:39
The balance of power on the Northern Plains had shifted decisively. The people who had once been pushed out of the forests of Minnesota were now the ones doing much of the pushing.
141:48
There is a fascinating twist in the timing of all this. The Lakota rise to power on the Northern Plains coincided almost exactly with the arrival of a brand new player in the region, the United States.
142:00
In 1803, the American government purchased from France the vast territory known as Louisiana, which included most of the lands where the Lakota now lived. Of course, the Lakota had not been consulted on this transaction and France had never really controlled these lands in the first place. It was a little like buying a house from someone who did not actually own it, while the actual residents were still living inside. President Thomas Jefferson then sent an expedition to explore the new territory, led by Meriwether Lewis and William Clark. Jefferson specifically instructed them to make a good impression on the Sioux, whom he had heard were a powerful and important nation.
142:36
He understood, at least on paper, that these were people the United States needed to get along with.
142:43
In the summer of 1804, as the expedition travelled up the Missouri River, its first encounter with members of the Osseti Sakowin went very well.
142:51
In late August, near a spot known as Calumet Bluff, they met a group of Yankton. The meeting was friendly, with speeches, gifts and smoking of the pipe.
143:01
A popular story from this meeting says that a baby boy born during the visit was wrapped in an American flag by Lewis himself and that the boy grew up to become a respected Yankton leader, known as Struck by the Rhee.
143:14
Whether every detail is accurate or not, it is a charming picture of a moment of goodwill.
143:19
The next encounter was a different matter.
143:22
In late September 1804, near the mouth of the Bad River, close to what is now the city of Pierre in South Dakota, the expedition met a group of Lakota of the Sikangi Band led by a chief named Black Buffalo. The Lakota controlled this stretch of the Missouri and they saw no reason why a boat full of strangers should simply sail through their territory without paying the customary tolls in goods as traders normally did.
143:46
The meeting quickly became tense. At one point Lakota warriors took hold of the rope attached to the expedition's boat and both sides prepared for a fight. Weapons were raised, tempers flared and for a few very long moments it looked as though the expedition might end right there.
144:02
Then Black Buffalo stepped in, took control of the rope himself and calmed the situation down.
144:09
The crisis passed and the Americans stayed for a few more days, attending feasts and dances before continuing up the river.
144:17
Clark later wrote about the Lakota in rather unflattering terms, describing them as a kind of river pirates.
144:24
From the Lakota point of view, of course, they were simply asking visitors to respect the rules of their road. Every toll booth operator in the world would probably understand.
144:34
This brief standoff on the Missouri was a sign of things to come. In 1804, the Lakota were at the height of their confidence, masters of the Northern Plains, entirely capable of deciding whether a small American expedition could pass through their country.
144:48
The United States, for its part, was a young nation still largely confined to the eastern half of the continent. For the moment the two meters equals, or perhaps with the Lakota holding the stronger hand, neither side could yet imagine how dramatically that balance would change over the next seventy years.
145:05
But the paths of the Lakota and the Americans had now crossed, and they would cross again, with far greater consequences, at a place called Little Bighorn.
145:15
while the Lakota were sizing up American boats on the Missouri. The Navajo were living in a very different landscape far to the southwest, among red canyons, sandstone mesas and high pine-covered plateaus. As we saw earlier, they call themselves Diné, the people, a name that links them to their distant Athabascan relatives in the north. Their homeland is Dineta, or in its broader sense Dinebiquea, the land of the people, and it has very clear borders, drawn not by surveyors but by the sacred story of creation.
145:46
It lies between four holy mountains. In the east stands Blanca Peak in Colorado, in the south rises Mount Taylor in New Mexico, in the west are the San Francisco Peaks near Flagstaff in Arizona, and in the north stands Hesperus Mountain in Colorado. According to tradition, the holy people placed these mountains to mark the boundaries of the world the Diné were meant to live in.
146:08
Leaving that space was not just a matter of moving house, it meant stepping outside the order of the universe, which explains a great deal about what happened later in this chapter. If one quality defines Navajo history, it is a remarkable talent for taking ideas from others and turning them into something entirely their own.
146:26
The newcomers from the north had arrived, as we know, as mobile hunters and gatherers. In the south-west they met the Pueblo peoples, expert farmers and craftspeople, and they learned from them. They began growing corn, beans and squash in the canyon bottoms. They picked up elements of Pueblo ceremony and art, and they learned to weave. That learning grew much deeper after the Pueblo revolt we described earlier. When the Spanish returned to New Mexico in the 1690s, many Pueblo families fled their towns and took refuge among the Navajo and Dineta. For a time, the two peoples lived side by side, intermarried and shared skills.
147:02
Archaeologists have found small stone fortresses on mesa tops from this era, with Pueblo-style masonry and Navajo pottery side by side. It was one of history's more productive house shares. From the Spanish, the Navajo acquired something just as important – sheep.
147:18
Spanish settlers had brought a hardy breed called the churro, a tough animal with long, silky wool that could survive heat, cold and thin grazing.
147:27
The Navajo took to sheep with enthusiasm, through trade and, let us be honest, through quite a few raids on Spanish flocks. Sheep soon became the centre of Navajo life. They provided meat, milk and above all wool, and a family's flock became a measure of its wealth and security. Horses arrived along the same routes, giving the Navajo greater mobility for herding, trading and travel.
147:50
Within a few generations, a people who had once arrived on foot from the north had become herders, farmers, riders and weavers all at once. Navajo weaving became famous across the continent. According to tradition, the art was taught to the Diné by Spider Woman, a holy person who showed them how to build a loom, with Spider Man providing the materials for it. Navajo women wove on upright looms, producing blankets of extraordinary quality, so tightly woven that some were said to hold water.
148:20
By the early 19th century, Navajo blankets were prized trade goods carried far beyond the southwest. Among the most valued were the striped blankets, later called chief blankets, which were so expensive that only wealthy and important people on the plains could afford them. Lakota and Cheyenne leaders wore them as symbols of status, so a blanket woven in an Arizona canyon might end up on the shoulders of a chief in Dakota, which makes it one of the earliest examples of high fashion-going national.
148:48
Later, Navajo weavers adapted to new markets again, producing rugs for American buyers and later still Navajo silversmiths who learned the craft from Mexican metal workers in the middle of the 19th century began creating the silver and turquoise jewellery that is now recognised around the world. The traditional Navajo home is the Hogan, a round or many-sided dwelling built of logs and covered with earth or bark.
149:11
Its doorway always faces east, toward the rising sun, so that the first thing to greet the family each morning is the light of a new day. The Hogan is more than a house. In Navajo tradition, the first Hogans were built by the holy people, and the dwelling itself is a sacred space, with its parts associated with the structure of the universe. It is the place where ceremonies take place, where families gather, and where the order of the world is reproduced on a small scale.
149:37
Not many homes come with a cosmological blueprint, but the Hogan does. At the heart of Navajo spiritual life is a concept called Hoju. It is often translated as beauty, harmony or balance, but it really means all of these at once, a state in which everything in the world, people, nature and the sacred is in its proper place and in the right relationship. Illness, misfortune and conflict are understood as signs that this balance has been disturbed. The purpose of Navajo ceremonies is to restore it.
150:08
The most fundamental of these is the blessing way, a ceremony used to bless a new home, protect a traveller, celebrate a marriage, honour a girl reaching womanhood or simply bring good fortune and harmony.
150:20
It is said to be the backbone of Navajo religion, the ceremony from which many others branch out. Some ceremonies are aimed at healing and they can last for several days and nights.
150:31
They are led by a specialist known in English as a singer or medicine person, called a Hatawi, who must memorise vast numbers of songs, prayers and ritual actions with complete accuracy. A single mistake might weaken the ceremony, so the training takes many years. It is a bit like memorising an entire opera, word for word, and then performing it from memory for nine nights straight, with no prompter.
150:55
Some healing ceremonies include sand paintings, intricate images created on the floor of the Hogan from coloured sand, crushed minerals, charcoal and pollen. They depict holy people and sacred scenes and they are made with great precision.
151:09
The person being healed sits on the painting so that the power of the holy people can pass into them and the sickness can be drawn out. When the ceremony is finished, the painting is carefully destroyed. It has done its work and its power should not linger.
151:23
Imagine spending hours creating a masterpiece and then sweeping it away on purpose. For the Navajo, that is exactly the point. Navajo society is organized around clans, and as among the Haudenosaunee they pass through the mother, a child is born into the clan of the mother and is also born for the clan of the father. Even today, when Navajo people introduce themselves formally, they name their clans, usually four of them, the mother's clan, the father's clan, the clan of the maternal grandfather, and the clan of the paternal grandfather. It is a very effective introduction.
151:56
Within a few sentences, everyone in the room knows who you are, where you fit, and whether you are related to them. It also tells you whom you cannot marry, since marriage within your own clans is forbidden, and here too the Navajo talent for absorbing others shows up clearly. Some Navajo clans trace their origins to Pueblo people, others to Ute, Apache or Mexican ancestors who joined the Dene over the centuries. There is even a clan whose name means the Mexican people.
152:23
The family tree of the Diné is a map of everyone they ever met. For centuries, relations between the Navajo and their neighbours followed a complicated rhythm. They traded with the pueblos and the Spanish settlers of New Mexico, exchanging blankets, hides and livestock for corn, metal tools and other goods.
152:41
but they also raided each other. Navajo raiders took sheep, horses and sometimes captives from Spanish and Pueblo settlements. Spanish and later Mexican raiders, along with Ute and other allies, struck back, taking Navajo livestock and Navajo women and children, many of whom were sold or forced into servitude in New Mexican households. By the middle of the 19th century, thousands of Navajo captives were living in such households. Each side had grievances against the other, and each raid seemed to justify the next. Peace agreements were made and broken many times, partly because, much like the Comanche, no single Navajo leader could speak for the whole people.
153:20
A treaty signed by one group of headmen did not bind families living a hundred kilometres away.
153:26
In 1846, the United States took New Mexico during its war with Mexico and the Americans inherited this long, tangled conflict. They signed treaties with Navajo leaders, built forts in Navajo country and demanded that raiding stop. Raids continued on both sides and so did misunderstandings. In 1849, an elderly and widely respected Navajo leader named Narbona who had spent years trying to keep the peace was killed by american soldiers during a dispute at a meeting held to negotiate it was a grim sign of things to come The decisive turn came during the American Civil War.
154:02
In 1862, General James Carlton took command in New Mexico. He was determined to end the Navajo conflict once and for all, and he had a plan that was both ambitious and harsh.
154:12
The Navajo would be removed from their homeland entirely and resettled at a place called Bosque Redondo on the Pecos River in eastern New Mexico, near a new post named Fort Sumner.
154:22
There, Carlton believed, they would become settled farmers under army supervision. The Navajo had not been consulted and it is safe to say they would not have voted for it. To carry out the plan, Carlton turned to Christopher Carson, better known as Kit Carson, the famous frontiersman and scout who was then serving as a colonel of New Mexico volunteers.
154:43
Beginning in 1863, Carson's troops moved through Navajo country using a strategy of scorched earth.
154:49
Rather than seeking out large battles, which the Navajo usually avoided, they destroyed the means of survival. They burned fields of corn, seized or killed sheep and horses, and destroyed hogans.
155:01
In the winter of 1864, they entered Canyon de Chely, one of the most sacred and protected places in Navajo country. Later that year, troops cut down the peach orchards that the Navajo had tended there for generations, thousands of trees.
155:14
The loss was not only economic – those orchards had been planted and cared for by grandparents and great-grandparents. Facing hunger and a bitter winter, thousands of Navajo began to surrender at the forts. What followed is remembered by the Navajo as the Long Walk. Between 1864 and 1866, somewhere between 8,000 and 9,000 Navajo were marched to Bosque Redondo in more than 50 separate groups.
155:38
The journey covered roughly 500 kilometres and most people made it on foot, including the elderly and children, often in the cold of winter, with not enough food or clothing. Many did not survive the journey. For the Navajo, this was more than a forced march. It meant crossing the boundaries set by the four sacred mountains, leaving the world that had been given to them. Bosque Redondo turned out to be a disaster from almost every point of view. The Navajo call it Huéldi, often understood as a place of suffering. The water of the Pecos River was alkaline and made people sick.
156:12
Firewood was so scarce that people had to walk great distances to find any at all. The crops planted there failed again and again, destroyed by insects, drought and floods. The army struggled to supply enough rations and much of what arrived was spoiled or of poor quality. disease spread through the crowded camps the navajo also had to share the reservation with several hundred mescalero apache who had been sent there earlier and who finding the conditions intolerable slipped away one night in 1865 Over the four years of the Navajo stay at Bosca Redondo, thousands died.
156:46
Even the army came to see the experiment as a failure, not least because it was extremely expensive. It is not often that a policy manages to be cruel, ineffective and over-budget all at once, but Bosca Redondo achieved it.
157:00
In 1868, a peace commission arrived, led by General William Tecumseh Sherman, the famous Civil War commander.
157:08
The Navajo leaders, including Barboncito and Manuelito, met with him. Sherman suggested that the Navajo might be moved to Indian Territory, in what is now Oklahoma.
157:18
babanchito responded with a powerful speech explaining that the navajo had been placed by the holy people between the four sacred mountains and that they could only live well in their own land he told sherman that he hoped to be sent home and that if he were he would never want to leave again sherman to his credit listened On 1 June 1868, the Navajo and the United States signed a treaty. It was a rare event in the history of American relations with native nations. Instead of removing a people further from their homeland, the treaty allowed them to return.
157:52
The reservation it created covered only a part of their former lands, but it lay within the sacred mountains.
157:59
When the news was announced, people wept with joy. In mid-June, a long column of Navajo set out from Bosque Redondo, this time heading west toward home. Elders later recalled that when they first saw Mount Taylor rising on the horizon, people cried and prayed, knowing that they had returned to the land of the Diné. The return was not easy. Their flocks were gone, their orchards destroyed, their homes in ruins. The government provided some sheep and goats to restart herds, along with tools and seeds, and the Navajo set about rebuilding with tremendous determination.
158:33
And they did more than rebuild.
158:35
Within a few decades, the population, which had fallen dramatically during the years of war and exile, began to grow steadily and flocks multiplied across the canyons and mesas.
158:46
The Navajo began a recovery that would turn them, over the following century, into the largest native nation in the United States. The Treaty of 1868 is still treasured today and the people sometimes call it the Old Paper. It was the document that brought them home. The Navajo had cousins in the mountains to the south and east, people who spoke closely related southern Athabascan languages and who had made the same long journey from the north. They were the Apache.
159:12
And true to the pattern we have seen throughout this story, the name Apache was not their own.
159:18
It most likely comes from a word in the Zuni language meaning something like enemy. In their own languages, Apache people call themselves Ende, Inde, or Dine, all variations of the same word meaning the people. At this point in our story, you could probably write a book titled Names My Neighbours Gave Me. The first thing to understand about the Apache is that there was never a single Apache nation.
159:41
They were a family of related peoples, each with its own territory, dialect and way of life.
159:47
The Chiricahua lived in the mountains of southeastern Arizona, southwestern New Mexico and northern Mexico and were themselves divided into several bands.
159:57
The Mescalero lived in the mountains of south-central New Mexico and took their name from mescal, the agave plant whose heart they roasted in large pits as a staple food.
160:07
The Jicarilla lived in northern New Mexico and southern Colorado. The Lipan, as we saw, had been pushed off the southern plains by the Comanche into Texas. And the western Apache, including groups such as the White Mountains, Cebuque, San Carlos and Tonto Apache, lived in the mountains and valleys of central and eastern Arizona. Each of these peoples made their own decisions, signed their own agreements and sometimes fought each other. lumping them all together as the Apache is a little like describing everyone from Lisbon to Moscow as Europeans and expecting them to sign a single treaty.
160:41
What united them was a deep knowledge of their land. The Apache homeland was some of the most rugged country on the continent, jagged mountain ranges rising out of hot deserts, deep canyons, hidden springs and high forests of pine and oak.
160:56
The Apache knew every water source, every pass, every cave and every edible plant. They lived in small mobile groups, often based on extended families, in homes called wickiups, dome-shaped shelters of branches covered with brush, grass or hides that could be built quickly and abandoned without regret. They hunted deer and other game, gathered acorns, pignon nuts and mesquite beans, roasted agave and sometimes grew small crops.
161:25
and they raided their neighbours for livestock and goods, a practice that, as we saw with the Comanche and the Navajo, was a regular part of the economy of the South West. Apache children were raised to be tough. Boys underwent rigorous training. They were sent to run long distances up mountain slopes, sometimes with a mouthful of water that they were not allowed to swallow, to teach them to breathe through the nose and control their thirst. They learned to go without food and sleep, to move silently, and to survive in the desert with almost nothing.
161:55
An adult Apache warrior could reportedly cover dozens of kilometres a day on foot over rough terrain, often faster than mounted soldiers who had to stop to rest and water their horses. Some modern fitness programmes claim to be extreme. Next to an Apache childhood, most of them look like a pleasant afternoon stroll. Girls were trained in endurance too, and the transition to womanhood was marked by one of the most important ceremonies in Apache life, the sunrise ceremony.
162:23
For four days, a young woman dances, runs and prays and is said to take on the power of white-painted woman, a central figure in Apache tradition. The ceremony is a celebration of strength, long life and the future of the community and it is still performed today. The Spanish had been dealing with the Apache since the late 16th century and they found them an extraordinarily difficult people to control.
162:47
Apache raids struck missions, ranches and mining towns across northern New Spain. To defend the frontier, the Spanish built a long chain of military forts known as Presidios, stretching across the northern borderlands from Texas to Sonora. In 1772, the Crown issued new regulations to reorganize this line, placing Presidios at intervals across the frontier. In practice, the line was more of a series of dots than a wall, and the Apache moved between them with ease. Then, in the 1780s, the Spanish tried a different approach, one that would sound familiar to anyone who remembers how they dealt with the Comanche.
163:22
They offered peace and regular rations. Apache groups that agreed to settle near the Presidios received food, cloth, tobacco and other goods. The program, sometimes called the Establishments of Peace, was not perfect, but for several decades it brought a significant reduction in violence. Many Apache families lived near the forts, and the frontier was quieter than it had been in generations. It turned out that keeping people fed was considerably cheaper than fighting them. A shocking discovery, apparently.
163:52
After Mexico won its independence in 1821, the new government could no longer afford the rations and by the early 1830s the system had collapsed.
164:02
Apache groups returned to raiding and the northern Mexican states, particularly Sonora and Chihuahua, were hit hard. Their response was a policy that turned the conflict into something far darker. In the 1830s, both states began offering bounties for Apache scalps. Bounty hunters, including Mexicans, Americans, and men from other native peoples were paid for proof of each Apache killed.
164:27
The policy was horrifying in principle and chaotic in practice. Since a scalp could not reveal who it came from, some bounty hunters attacked peaceful Apache communities and some reportedly targeted other native peoples or even Mexican villagers.
164:41
The Apache, in turn, sought revenge for every attack and the cycle of vengeance spun faster and faster.
164:48
The northern Mexican frontier became trapped in a feud that seemed to have no end.
164:52
One episode from this era would shape the life of the most famous Apache of all.
164:57
In 1858, Mexican troops attacked an Apache camp near the town of Janos in Chihuahua while many of the men were away trading in town.
165:06
Among those who died were the mother, the young wife, and the three small children of a young Bedonkoje Apache man named Goyacla. He later said that after that day, he could never again feel at peace with Mexico. The world would come to know him by another name, Geronimo. In 1848, at the end of the Mexican-American War, much of the Apache homeland passed from Mexico to the United States, and in 1853 another strip of land in southern Arizona and New Mexico followed. At first some Apache leaders were cautiously optimistic about the Americans, who were after all enemies of Mexico.
165:40
That optimism did not last.
165:43
American miners and settlers began moving into Apache country and the conflict that had raged with Mexico shifted toward the new arrivals.
165:51
The turning point came in February 1861 at Apache Pass in southeastern Arizona, a vital route with a reliable spring and a stagecoach station. A boy had been taken from a ranch in the area and a young army lieutenant named George Bascom was sent to recover him. Bascom invited the Chokun and Chiricahua leader Cochise to a meeting in his tent. Cochise came, along with members of his family, and denied having anything to do with the boy, which was true. Bascom did not believe him and tried to hold him prisoner until the boy was returned. Cochise drew his knife, cut through the wall of the tent and escaped.
166:24
Then both sides took hostages and the situation spiralled out of control, ending in the deaths of hostages on both sides. The incident, known as the Bascom affair, turned Cochise from a cautious neighbour into a determined enemy and it triggered roughly a decade of war.
166:39
The boy himself, as it turns out, later grew up to become an army scout and interpreter known as Mickey Free.
166:45
History has a strange sense of humour. Cochise was joined in this struggle by his father-in-law, Mangus Coloradas, a leader of the Chihene and Bedoncohe Apache.
166:56
Mangus Coloradas, whose name means red sleeves in Spanish, was famous for his great height, his strength, and his skill as a diplomat and war leader. For decades he had been one of the most influential Apache leaders in the region. In January 1863, he approached a group of American soldiers and prospectors under a flag of truce to discuss peace.
167:17
Instead, he was seized and taken to a military post, where he was killed by his guards that night.
167:23
The official report claimed he had been trying to escape. Few people, then or now, have believed that version. For the Apache, it was the ultimate confirmation that American promises could not be trusted.
167:35
Cochise continued to fight until 1872, when General Oliver Otis Howard made the long, dangerous journey into the Dragoon Mountains to meet him. Howard was guided by a man named Tom Jeffords, a former mail contractor who had, remarkably, become a personal friend of Cochise. the meeting led to a peace agreement and a reservation for the Chiricahua in their own country, with Jeffords as the agent. Cochise kept the peace until his death in 1874. Two years later, the government closed the reservation and ordered the Chiricahua to move to the San Carlos Reservation, a hot, crowded and malaria-ridden stretch of land along the Gila River that soldiers themselves nicknamed Hell's Forty Acres.
168:17
If the nickname was used by the people running the place, you can imagine how the people forced to live there felt about it.
168:24
Many Apache refused to stay at San Carlos and over the next decade small groups repeatedly broke away.
168:30
One of the most formidable leaders of this era was Victorio, a Chihene chief who wanted only one thing, to live in his people's homeland around the springs of Ojo Caliente in New Mexico. When that request was denied, he took his people out and from 1879 to 1880 he led a campaign across New Mexico, Texas and northern Mexico that baffled both the American and Mexican armies. Fighting alongside him was his sister, Lozen, one of the most remarkable figures in Apache history. She was a skilled rider and warrior, and her people believed she had a spiritual power to sense the direction of enemies.
169:07
In October 1880, Victorio and many of his followers were surrounded by Mexican forces at Tres Castillos in Chihuahua, where he died. That brings us back to Geronimo. It is worth clearing up one popular misconception. Geronimo was never a chief. He was a medicine man and a war leader, respected for his spiritual power, his courage and his remarkable ability to evade pursuit.
169:30
His followers believed he could see events before they happened and even delay the dawn to give them time to escape. His name, Geronimo, is said to have come from Mexican soldiers who, during a battle, called out to St. Jerome or Geronimo in Spanish as he charged at them.
169:47
Between 1876 and 1886, he broke out of the reservation several times, leading small groups into the mountains of Arizona and Mexico.
169:57
What made these campaigns so astonishing was the imbalance of numbers.
170:01
In the final campaign of 1885 to 1886, Geronimo's group consisted of only a few dozen people, including women and children, and the number of actual fighters was often well under 50, at times fewer than 20. Against them, the United States deployed around 5,000 soldiers, roughly a quarter of the entire US Army at that time, while thousands of Mexican troops searched for them south of the border.
170:26
For months, this tiny group crossed mountains and deserts, slipping through cordons and vanishing into the Sierra Madre. It is one of the most remarkable feats of endurance and evasion in military history. The army, meanwhile, was finding out what it was like to look for a needle in a haystack, when the needle knows the haystack far better than you do.
170:45
The officer who finally understood how to fight this kind of war was General George Crook. His key insight was simple. Only Apache could find Apache. He recruited large numbers of Apache scouts, many of them from Western Apache groups and some even from among the Chiricahua themselves.
171:02
These scouts knew the land, the tactics and the hiding places and they led the troops deep into the Sierra Madre, places the army could never have found alone.
171:12
In March 1886, Crook negotiated a surrender with Geronimo in Mexico, but on the way back, Geronimo and a small group slipped away again. Crook was replaced by General Nelson Miles who poured more soldiers into the hunt. But in the end, it was not the soldiers who brought Geronimo in.
171:29
Lieutenant Charles Gatewood, accompanied by two Chiricahua scouts named Martin and Cayeta, found Geronimo in Mexico and persuaded him that his people's situation was hopeless and that many of their relatives had already been sent away. On 4 September 1886, at Skeleton Canyon in Arizona, Geronimo formally surrendered to General Miles. What followed is one of the most bitter episodes of the entire story. The government did not simply imprison Geronimo and his fighters. It sent away the entire Chiricahua people, including the families who had stayed peacefully on the reservation and including the very Chiricahua scouts who had served the army and helped bring Geronimo in.
172:07
Martin and Caeta, the two men who had found him, were sent into exile along with everyone else. They were all loaded onto trains and shipped to Florida as prisoners of war.
172:18
Some were held at Fort Marion in St. Augustine, others at Fort Pickens near Pensacola. Many of the children were sent away to a boarding school in Pennsylvania, a subject we will return to. The humid climate and poor conditions took a heavy toll, and many people died of disease.
172:34
In 1888, most of the prisoners were moved to Mount Vernon Barracks in Alabama and in 1894 to Fort Sill in what is now Oklahoma, on lands lent by the Comanche in Kiowa.
172:45
Geronimo spent the rest of his life as a prisoner of war.
172:49
Over time, he became an unusual kind of celebrity. He appeared at fairs and exhibitions, including the 1904 World's Fair in St. Louis, where he sold signed photographs of himself and bows and arrows he had made, often for very good prices. He clearly understood the value of his own name better than many marketing departments do today.
173:09
In 1905, he rode in the inaugural parade of President Theodore Roosevelt, and he used the opportunity to ask the President to let his people return home. The answer was no.
173:19
Geronimo died at Fort Sill in 1909, still officially a prisoner. Decades later, American paratroopers began shouting his name as they jumped out of airplanes, which would surely have puzzled him.
173:31
The Chiricahua remained prisoners of war until 1913, 27 years after Geronimo's surrender.
173:38
When they were finally released, they were given a choice. Some chose to move to the Mescalero Apache Reservation in New Mexico, closer to their old homeland. Others decided to stay in Oklahoma, where their descendants live today.
173:52
Neither group was allowed to return to the mountains of Arizona that Cochise and Mangus Coloradas had defended, The war in the desert had ended, but for the Shirakawa the road home remained closed. While the deserts of Arizona were sliding into decades of war, the final struggle for the Great Plains was already underway and it began not on the open grasslands but back where the Sioux story started, in Minnesota.
174:15
By the 1850s, the Dakota who had remained in the East had signed treaties giving up most of their land in exchange for a narrow reservation along the Minnesota River and a promise of yearly payments in money and food. The payments were supposed to support people who could no longer hunt across their old territory. In practice, they were often late and much of the money ended up in the hands of traders who claimed it to cover debts they said the Dakota owed them, debts that were very difficult to verify. In the summer of 1862, the situation became desperate. Crops had failed the year before and many Dakota families were going hungry.
174:49
The annual payment was late again, delayed in part because the government in Washington was busy with the Civil War and argued over whether to pay in gold or paper money. The traders refused to give any more food on credit. One of them is reported to have said that if the Dakota were hungry, they could eat grass. It may be one of the worst pieces of public relations in American history.
175:10
In August 1862, after a confrontation in which several settlers were killed by a small group of young Dakota men, the tension exploded.
175:19
A respected leader named Little Crow, who had long tried to work with the Americans and had even travelled to Washington, was asked to lead his people into war. He warned them that they could not win, but he agreed to stand with them. Over the following weeks, Dakota fighters attacked settlements, farms and towns across southwestern Minnesota. Hundreds of settlers died and many Dakota did as well. It was one of the deadliest conflicts between settlers and native people in American history.
175:48
Many Dakota opposed the war, and some protected settlers and helped captives escape.
175:53
By late September, the Dakota forces had been defeated, and most of those who had not fled surrendered.
175:59
What came next was swift and deeply troubling. A military commission tried nearly 400 Dakota men in a matter of weeks. Some trials lasted only a few minutes. The accused had no lawyers, and many did not understand the proceedings, which were held in English. Over 300 men were sentenced to death.
176:17
President Abraham Lincoln personally reviewed the cases and reduced the list to those accused of the most serious crimes.
176:24
On 26 December 1862, in the town of Mankato, 38 Dakota men were hanged at the same time. It remains the largest mass execution in the history of the United States. The following year, the Dakota were expelled from Minnesota altogether and hundreds of families were held over the winter in a camp below Fort Snelling, where many died.
176:46
Little Crow himself was killed in 1863 while picking berries. Every December today, Dakota riders travel on horseback to Mankato in a memorial ride to remember the 38 and to pray for healing.
176:59
Further west, the Lakota were facing a new threat. In the 1860s, gold was discovered in Montana, and a route called the Bozeman Trail was opened to carry miners and settlers there. The trail ran straight through the Powder River country, some of the richest hunting grounds left of the Lakota and their Cheyenne and Arapaho allies.
177:18
To protect the travellers, the army built a line of forts along the trail. From the Lakota point of view, this was an invasion of their best remaining bison lands, and they responded with a determined campaign led by the Oglala leader Red Cloud. The conflict became known as Red Cloud's War. Its most famous moment came on 21 December 1866 near Fort Phil Kearney in what is now Wyoming. A confident young officer named Captain William Fetterman, who is said to have boasted that with 80 men he could ride through the entire Sioux Nation, led a detachment out of the fort to rescue a woodcutting party.
177:52
A small group of warriors, including a young Oglala named Crazy Horse, acted as decoys, staying just out of reach and luring the soldiers over a ridge. On the other side, a large force of Lakota, Cheyenne and Arapaho was waiting. Within a short time, Fetterman and all his men, 81 soldiers in total, were dead.
178:12
As a test of his boast it was conclusive, though not in the way he had hoped. The army was stunned and the Bozeman trail became nearly impossible to use. In 1868 the government agreed to negotiate. At Fort Laramie a treaty was signed that gave the Lakota almost everything they had asked for. the army would abandon the forts along the Bozeman Trail. The Great Sioux Reservation was established, covering all of what is now western South Dakota, including the Black Hills, and it was set aside for the absolute and undisturbed use of the Lakota, The Powder River country was recognised as unceded hunting territory.
178:48
Red Cloud refused to sign until the soldiers had actually left. When they did, the Lakota burned the empty forts. It was one of the very few wars that the United States clearly lost to a native nation and the treaty was a remarkable victory.
179:02
For a few short years, it looked as if the Lakota had secured their future. That future lasted about six years.
179:10
In 1874, Lieutenant Colonel George Armstrong Custer led a large military expedition into the Black Hills, officially to survey the area and find a site for a fort.
179:20
The expedition included geologists and they found gold. Custer's reports made sure everyone knew about it and newspapers across the country carried the news. Within months, thousands of prospectors were pouring into the hills in clear violation of the treaty.
179:36
The army made a few half-hearted attempts to keep them out then gave up. The government offered to buy the Black Hills, but the Lakota refused. For a people who saw the hills as sacred as we saw earlier, it was a little like offering to buy someone's cathedral to use as a quarry.
179:51
Washington then changed tactics. The government ordered all Lakota to report to the agencies by the end of January 1876. Those who did not would be considered hostile. Many of the free-roaming bands living in the Powder River country as the treaty allowed did not even receive the order in time, and travelling with families across the plains in the middle of winter was nearly impossible. So when the deadline passed, the army launched a campaign to force them in. By the summer of 1876, a huge camp had gathered along a river in Montana that the Americans called the Little Bighorn and the Lakota called the Greasy Grass.
180:26
It held Lakota from several bands, along with Cheyenne and some Arapaho, perhaps as many as six to eight thousand people in all.
180:34
One of the most influential figures in the camp was Sitting Bull, a hunk-papa-holy man and leader known for his wisdom and his refusal to accept life on the reservation. A few weeks earlier, during a sun dance, he had experienced a vision of soldiers falling upside down into the camp, which people interpreted as a sign of a great victory to come.
180:54
On 25 June 1876, Custer's 7th Cavalry Regiment approached the camp. Custer badly underestimated its size, and he divided his regiment into several groups, sending some of them to attack from different directions. It was not a good decision. The warriors in the camp, led by figures such as Crazy Horse, Gaul, and the Cheyenne leader Two Moons, responded with overwhelming force. Within a short time, Custer and every soldier in the battalion under his direct command were dead. The other parts of the regiment survived under siege until the next day.
181:26
In total, more than 260 soldiers, scouts and civilians with the regiment were killed. It was the most famous defeat of the US Army in the Wars of the West, and the news reached the eastern cities just as the country was celebrating its 100th birthday in July 1876. It is fair to say it spoiled the party, but the victory at the greasy grass turned out to be the last great triumph of the Free Lakota. The government responded by sending more troops, and the army adopted a new strategy, winter campaigns.
181:58
In winter, the great camps broke up into smaller groups, the horses were weak from lack of grass, and people depended on their stored food. Soldiers attacked these winter camps, destroying tipis, supplies, and horses. Hungry and exhausted, band after band surrendered. Sitting Bull led his followers across the border into Canada, which the Lakota called Grandmother's Land, after Queen Victoria.
182:23
Crazy Horse surrendered at Camp Robinson in Nebraska in May 1877.
182:28
A few months later in September, amid rumours and suspicions, soldiers attempted to arrest him and during the struggle he was fatally wounded. He was about 35 years old. In 1877, Congress passed a law taking the Black Hills from the Lakota. That law, as we will see, would be challenged a century later. The same pattern was unfolding on the Southern Plains. In 1874, Comanche, Kiowa, Cheyenne and Arapaho fighters, angry at the destruction of the bison herds and at the failures of the reservation system, launched a campaign that became known as the Red River War.
183:03
It began with an attack on a post of buffalo hunters at adobe walls in the Texas panhandle, in which a young Quahadi Comanche leader named Quanna played a prominent role. The army responded by sending several columns from different directions into the heart of the Llano Estacado, the old stronghold of the Quahadi that we met earlier.
183:21
The decisive moment came in September 1874 in Palo Duro Canyon, a deep, hidden canyon in the Texas panhandle where several bands had set up their winter camps. Colonel Ronald McKenzie and his cavalry found a way down into the canyon and attacked. Few people were killed in the fighting itself because most of the families managed to escape, but McKenzie captured around 1,400 horses. He kept some for his scouts and ordered more than a thousand of the rest to be shot so that they could never be recovered. He also burned the camps with their teepees and winter food supplies.
183:55
For a people whose entire way of life was built on the horse, as we have seen throughout this story, it was a devastating blow. Without horses, there was no hunting, no travel and no resistance.
184:07
Over the following months, hungry bands came in to surrender. The last to come in were the Quahadi, led by Quanah. His story is one of the most extraordinary in American history. His mother, Cynthia Ann Parker, had been captured as a girl of around nine in 1836 when Comanche and Allied warriors raided her family's settlement in Texas. She was adopted into a Comanche family, grew up Comanche, married a war leader named Peter Nakona and had three children, including Quanah.
184:36
In 1860, Texas Rangers attacked her camp and took her back to her white relatives. By then she had lived almost her entire life as a Comanche and she never adjusted to her old family's world. She tried more than once to return to her people and died about a decade later, deeply unhappy. Her son, meanwhile, became one of the most respected leaders of the Quahadi.
184:59
On 2 June 1875, Kwanna led his people into Fort Sill in Indian Territory and surrendered. The Free Comanche, the masters of the Southern Plains, had come to the end of their road. Behind all of these defeats stood a single enormous catastrophe, the destruction of the bison.
185:16
At the start of the 19th century, there were tens of millions of bison on the plains, possibly 30 million or more. As we saw, the bison provided the plains peoples with nearly everything. But in the early 1870s, new tanning methods made bison hides valuable for industrial leather, especially for the belts that drove machinery in factories in the East and in Europe. At the same time, new railroads crossed the plains, making it easy to ship hides to market.
185:42
Professional hide hunters with powerful long-range rifles moved onto the plains in large numbers. A skilled hunter could kill dozens of bison in a single day, often taking only the hide and leaving the rest. Many army officers and politicians openly approved of the slaughter, understanding that without the bison, the plains nations would be forced onto the reservations. The southern herd was largely gone by the late 1870s, and the northern herd collapsed a few years later.
186:09
By the end of the 1880s, a naturalist named William Hornaday tried to count the surviving bison in North America. He came up with a figure of roughly a thousand animals and only a few hundred of them were living in the wild.
186:22
In a single human generation, an animal that had once covered the plains so densely that travellers said herds took days to pass by had been brought to the very edge of extinction. With it went the economic foundation of the great horse cultures that had risen in the 18th century. The wars on the plains had been fought with rifles and cavalry, but in the end they were decided by the disappearance of the bison.
186:45
Once the armed resistance on the plains and in the deserts had come to an end, a different kind of campaign began. Its target was no longer warriors or horses but land, language, religion and family.
186:57
Many American reformers of the late 19th century considered themselves friends of the native peoples. They believed that the only way for native nations to survive was to stop being native nations at all, to give up their communal lands, their languages and their traditions, and to become individual American farmers and citizens. In their view, this was kindness. To the people on the receiving end, it often felt like the war had simply continued by other means.
187:21
The centrepiece of this policy was a law passed in 1887 known as the Dawes Act, after Senator Henry Dawes of Massachusetts.
187:30
Reservation lands had generally been held in common by each nation. The Dawes Act changed that. It divided reservations into individual plots, called allotments, typically 160 acres for the head of a family and smaller amounts for others. The idea was that every native family would become a private landowner, farming its own piece of land like a homesteader. There was a catch, and it was a very large one. Once every eligible person had received an allotment, the remaining land was declared surplus and could be open to non-native settlers.
188:01
Since reservations were often far larger than the total of the allotments, enormous areas were classified as surplus and sold off. The results were dramatic.
188:10
Much of the allotted land was unsuitable for small-scale farming, especially on the dry plains, and many families had neither the tools, the money, nor the training to farm it. Over time, many allotments were sold, often under pressure, through fraud, or to pay debts and taxes.
188:28
In 1887, Native nations held around 138 million acres of land.
188:34
By 1934, when the policy was finally ended, they held around 48 million acres. Roughly two-thirds of native land had been lost in less than 50 years. The Comanche, who had once controlled Comanche area, saw the remaining lands of their reservation in Oklahoma divided up and the surplus opened to settlers in 1901 through a land lottery. It was quite a journey, from ruling a territory larger than many European countries to having your neighbours chosen by a raffle. Interestingly, one people largely escaped the worst of allotment, and they were the Navajo.
189:07
Their reservation lay in dry, rugged desert country that settlers generally did not want, and much of it was simply not allotted. In a strange twist, the very harshness of the land protected it. In fact, while other nations were losing land, the Navajo reservation was growing. As their population increased after the return from Bosque Redondo and their flock spread across the surrounding country, the government expanded the reservation repeatedly through a series of orders and laws until it was several times larger than the territory set aside in 1868.
189:39
It is one of the rare cases in this period of a native nation gaining land rather than losing it.
189:45
The second great pillar of the assimilation policy was education, and it centered on boarding schools.
189:50
The most famous of these was the Carlisle Indian Industrial School in Pennsylvania, founded in 1879 by an army officer named Richard Henry Pratt. Pratt had previously been in charge of native prisoners held at Fort Marion in Florida, where he experimented with teaching them English and Christianity. He became convinced that native people could be transformed if they were removed from their communities at a young age. His philosophy is often summed up in a phrase he used in a speech, that the aim was to kill the Indian in him and save the man.
190:21
Pratt considered this a progressive idea, an alternative to the view, common at the time, that native people should simply be left to die out. That tells you something about how low the bar was. The first students at Carlisle included Lakota children from the Rosebud and Pine Ridge agencies, as well as children from many other nations.
190:40
Later, as we mentioned, many of the Chiricahua Apache children held in Florida were sent there too. On arrival, children were stripped of everything that connected them to home. Their hair was cut short, which for many peoples, including the Lakota, was a sign of mourning, so to the children it could feel like a funeral. Their traditional clothing was taken away and replaced with military-style uniforms. They were given new English names, sometimes chosen by pointing at a list on a blackboard. Speaking their own languages was forbidden and often punished. Their days were organised like an army camp, with bugles, marching and drills.
191:14
They were taught to see their own families' beliefs and traditions as backward, Carlisle became the model for a whole system. By the early 20th century there were hundreds of boarding schools for native children across the United States, some run by the government and others by churches.
191:29
Many children were sent far from home for years at a time, sometimes without seeing their families at all.
191:35
Conditions in many schools were harsh, with poor food, crowded dormitories and outbreaks of disease. A significant number of children died and were buried far from home. At Carlisle alone, the school cemetery contains the graves of nearly 200 children, and in recent years several native nations have worked to bring some of them back to be buried among their own people.
191:56
In 2022 and 2024, the US Department of the Interior published reports documenting more than 400 federal boarding schools and the deaths of many hundreds of children, while acknowledging that the true number was likely higher.
192:11
The impact of these schools did not end when the children grew up.
192:15
Many returned home unable to speak their own language well, unfamiliar with the ceremonies of their people, and uncomfortable in both worlds.
192:23
When they had children of their own, some chose not to teach them their native language, to spare them the punishments they themselves had suffered.
192:31
In this way, the loss passed from one generation to the next, and many native communities today still feel its effects. It is important to add that the story is not only one of a loss. Some students used the skills they acquired to defend their nations, becoming lawyers, writers and activists.
192:48
One Carlisle student, a Sack and Fox athlete named Jim Thorpe, won two gold medals at the 1912 Olympic Games in Stockholm, in the pentathlon and the decathlon, and is still considered one of the greatest athletes of the 20th century.
193:02
But these achievements came despite the system, not because of its goals. On the plains, meanwhile, life on the reservations was grim, The bison were gone, rations were often inadequate, and the government had cut the size of the Great Sioux Reservation again in 1889, dividing it into several smaller reservations. Traditional ceremonies such as the Sundance had been banned. Many people felt that their world had been taken away and that nothing could bring it back. It was into this atmosphere of despair that a new religious movement arrived from the West.
193:34
Its prophet was a northern Paiute man from Nevada named Wovica, also known by the English name Jack Wilson.
193:41
Around the beginning of 1889, during a solar eclipse, he experienced a powerful vision. He said that he had been taken to the spirit world, where he had seen the ancestors living happily and the land renewed. His message was one of peace. People should live honestly, work, avoid fighting, and perform a special circle dance. If they did, the world would be renewed, the dead would return, the bison would come back, and the old way of life would be restored. The dance became known as the Ghost Dance, and the message spread rapidly from nation to nation across the West.
194:14
Lakota delegates travelled to Nevada to meet Wavoka, and they brought the Ghost Dance back to their reservations.
194:20
In the Lakota version, some dancers wore special ghost shirts painted with sacred symbols which many believed could protect them.
194:28
American officials, already nervous, saw the dance as a sign of a coming uprising. Newspapers spread alarming stories. In fact, the dance itself was a religious movement, not a military one, but that distinction was lost on the authorities. Troops were sent to the reservations. At the Standing Rock Reservation, the government agent believed that Sitting Bull, who had returned from Canada in 1881 and was living quietly in his cabin, was encouraging the dance.
194:56
On the morning of 15 December 1890, Lakota members of the Reservation Police were sent to arrest him. A crowd of his supporters gathered, a struggle broke out and shots were fired. Sitting Bull was killed along with several of his followers and several of the police officers. It was a tragic end for one of the most respected leaders in Lakota history and it was carried out painfully by members of his own people working for the government.
195:22
Many of Sitting Bull's followers fled south and joined a band of Nikonju Lakota led by a chief named Spotted Elk, also known as Bigfoot, who was travelling toward the Pine Ridge Reservation. Spotted Elk was seriously ill with pneumonia On 28 December, the band was intercepted by soldiers of the 7th Cavalry, the same regiment that had fought at the Little Bighorn and taken to a camp beside Wounded Knee Creek.
195:48
The next morning, on 29 December 1890, the soldiers began to disarm the Lakota. During the search, a shot was fired, and in the chaos that followed, the soldiers opened fire, including with rapid firing cannons placed on a hill above the camp. When the firing stopped, somewhere between 250 and 300 Lakota had been killed, many of them women, children and elderly people. Around 25 soldiers also died, some of them likely from their own side's fire in the confusion.
196:19
Days later, after a blizzard had passed, the Lakota who died there were buried together in a single grave on the hill.
196:26
Wounded knee became a symbol of the end of an era and of a grief that the Lakota carry to this day.
196:32
And yet, even in these darkest decades, the story of these nations is also a story of adaptation and survival. Quanah Parker, the last Comanche leader to surrender, is perhaps the most striking example. After coming to Fort Sill, he quickly learned the new rules of the game and decided to play it better than almost anyone. he leased Comanche grazing lands to Texas cattle ranchers, bringing income to his people and became a successful rancher himself. He built a large two-story house that became known as the Star House because of the stars painted on its roof.
197:03
He served as a judge on the reservation's court, travelled to Washington to negotiate on behalf of the Comanche and invested in a local railroad. He became friends with powerful Americans, including President Theodore Roosevelt, who joined him on a wolf hunt in Oklahoma in 1905.
197:20
At the same time, he refused to give up some of his own traditions. He kept several wives, which eventually cost him his position as a judge, and he became a leading supporter of a new spiritual practice centered on the peyote cactus, which later developed into the Native American church. He managed to live in two worlds at once, and to bargain with the government on something closer to equal terms than almost any native leader of his time.
197:45
When he died in 1911, he was one of the most famous Native Americans in the country. The Navajo, too, were growing stronger. Their population, which had fallen to a few thousand during the years of exile, increased steadily in the decades after 1868, reaching tens of thousands by the early 20th century.
198:03
Their sheepherds multiplied, their weaving and silverwork found new markets through trading posts, and as we saw, their reservation kept expanding. In 1923, partly because oil companies wanted to sign leases for drilling on Navajo land, the government helped create a Navajo Tribal Council, the beginning of the modern Navajo government. It was created partly for the convenience of the oil companies, but it would become the foundation of a strong national government.
198:30
In 1924, Congress passed the Indian Citizenship Act, which made all native people born in the United States citizens.
198:38
Many had already become citizens through allotment, through military service or through other laws, but now the status was universal.
198:46
One reason for the law was gratitude. Thousands of native men had volunteered to fight in the First World War, even though many of them were not citizens of the country they were fighting for. Citizenship, however, did not automatically bring equal rights. Some states, including Arizona and New Mexico, continued to prevent native people from voting until 1948, and others for even longer.
199:10
and not every native nation welcomed the law. The Haudenosaunee, for example, regarded themselves as separate sovereign nations, and they saw citizenship imposed by another country without their consent as a threat to that sovereignty rather than a gift. That position, as we will see, would shape the way they interact with the world to this day. It would be easy to end the story there at the close of the nineteenth century, with the bison gone, the reservations shrinking and the boarding schools at work.
199:38
Many history books did exactly that, describing Native Americans as a vanishing people whose story was essentially over. There was just one problem with that version. The people in question did not vanish, and in the 20th century some of the very things the government had tried hardest to erase turned out to be among the most valuable assets the United States possessed.
200:00
The most famous example begins in 1942. The United States had entered the Second World War and in the Pacific the Marine Corps faced a serious problem.
200:10
Japanese intelligence was very good at intercepting and breaking American military codes and coded messages that took a long time to encrypt and decrypt were too slow for the chaos of combat.
200:20
A man named Philip Johnston, the son of a missionary who had grown up on the Navajo reservation and spoke the language, suggested an unusual solution. The Navajo language was extraordinarily complex. It had no written form in common use at the time and it was spoken by almost no one outside the Navajo nation. A code built on it, he argued, would be nearly impossible to crack. The Marines agreed to a test and in May 1942, 29 young Navajo men were recruited.
200:48
They became known as the original 29. At Camp Pendleton in California, they developed a code from scratch. For military terms that did not exist in Navajo, they used everyday words from their own world. A submarine became an iron fish, a tank became a tortoise, a fighter plane became a hummingbird and a bomber became a buzzard. Some names had a touch of humour. Adolf Hitler, for example, was referred to by a term that translates roughly as moustache smeller. For words that had to be spelled out, they created an alphabet in which each letter was represented by a Navajo word for an animal or object.
201:24
The first letter of the English word gave the letter, so the Navajo word for ant could stand for A and the word for bear could stand for B. To make it even harder to break, several different Navajo words could be used for the same letter. The code was memorised, not written down in the field, and a trained code talker could encode, transmit and decode a message in a fraction of the time a machine needed. The programme grew until roughly 400 Navajo served as code talkers. They took part in every major marine operation in the Pacific, including Guadalcanal, Tarawa, Saipan and Okinawa.
201:59
At Iwo Jima in 1945, six code talkers working around the clock in the first two days of the battle sent and received more than 800 messages without a single error.
202:09
A Marine signal officer later said that without the Navajo, the Marines would never have taken the island. The Japanese never managed to break the code. There was a deep irony in all of this. Many of the code talkers had attended boarding schools where, as we saw, they had been punished for speaking Navajo. The same language that teachers had tried to wash out of their mouths was now helping to win the war.
202:31
After the war ended, the Code Talkers were told to keep their work secret because the military thought the Code might be needed again. The programme was declassified only in 1968 and official recognition took even longer. In 2001, the surviving members of the original 29, along with the families of those who had passed away, received the Congressional Gold Medal while the other Code Talkers received silver medals. The last of the original 29, Chester Nez, died in 2014.
203:00
Today, 14 August is celebrated as Navajo Code Talkers' Day. The Navajo were not the only ones. Before the United States even entered the war, the Army recruited a group of 17 young Comanche men to develop a code in their own language.
203:14
Fourteen of them served in Europe with the 4th Infantry Division and on 6 June 1944 they landed on Utah Beach in Normandy as part of the D-Day invasion.
203:24
One of their first messages from the beach reported that they had landed, but in the wrong place.
203:29
Like the Navajo, they invented words for things that did not exist in their language. A tank was a turtle, a machine gun was a sewing machine, and Hitler was called by a term that translated as crazy white man.
203:42
Their code was never broken either. The descendants of the most feared riders of the Southern Plains were now carrying messages across the beaches of France. Meanwhile, high above the streets of New York, another native nation was building a very different kind of reputation.
203:57
In 1886, the Dominion Bridge Company began constructing a railway bridge across the St. Lawrence River on land belonging to the Mohawk community of Kahnawake near Montreal.
204:07
As part of the agreement, the company hired local Mohawk men as labourers The managers soon noticed something. The Mohawk workers had no hesitation about climbing onto the narrow steel beams high above the river and working there with extraordinary skill and calm. They were quickly trained as riveters and iron workers, and the profession spread through the community, passed down from fathers to sons.
204:31
There is a popular myth that Mohawk ironworkers were simply born without a fear of heights.
204:36
Mohawk workers themselves have always rejected this idea. They felt the fear like anyone else. They just learned to manage it, and they took pride in doing a dangerous job well. The danger was very real.
204:48
In 1907, the Quebec Bridge collapsed during construction and 33 Mohawk men from Kahnawake were among those killed. The community was devastated. Afterward, the women of Kahnawake insisted that the men spread out and work on different projects so that a single accident could never again take so many from one community.
205:09
In the 1920s and 1930s, Mohawk iron workers came to New York in large numbers. So many settled in one Brooklyn neighborhood that it became known as Little Kornowaga after an older name for Kahnawake. They worked on some of the most famous structures in the city, including the Empire State Building, the Chrysler Building, the George Washington Bridge, Rockefeller Center, and later the World Trade Center. and when the towers fell in 2001, Mohawk iron workers were among those who came to help with the work of clearing the site.
205:39
Many of them later helped build the new One World Trade Centre. The people of the Longhouse, as it turns out, also built some of the tallest houses in the world. The Haudenosaunee have also continued to insist, in very practical ways, on their status as sovereign nations. As we saw, many of them did not accept American citizenship as something imposed from outside. Since the 1920s, Haudenosaunee travellers have used passports issued by their own Confederacy. In 1923, a Cayuga leader named Descaher travelled to Geneva on a Haudenosaunee passport to appeal to the League of Nations for recognition of his people's sovereignty.
206:16
The Confederacy has continued to issue its own passports since then. Not every country accepts them, which has produced some memorable moments. In 2010, the Haudenosaunee national lacrosse team was unable to travel to the World Championships in England because the British government would not accept their passports.
206:33
That was especially ironic because lacrosse itself is a Haudenosaunee game, sometimes called the creator's game. Imagine the inventors of a sport being unable to attend its world championship because of a paperwork dispute.
206:46
On the plains, the struggle for land and recognition took a more dramatic turn in the 1970s. In February 1973, around 200 activists of the American Indian Movement, together with Oglala Lakota residents of the Pine Ridge Reservation, occupied the village of Wounded Knee, the site of the tragedy of 1890.
207:06
They were protesting against the tribal government on the reservation, against broken treaties, and against the poverty and injustice their communities faced.
207:15
Federal agents and police surrounded the village and the standoff lasted 71 days, attracting attention from around the world. Shots were exchanged and two native men were killed during the siege.
207:27
In the middle of it, the actor Marlon Brando declined to accept his Academy Award, sending Sachin Littlefeather, an Apache and Yaqui activist, to the ceremony to explain that he was protesting the treatment of Native Americans by the film industry and the events at Wounded Knee. The occupation ended in May 1973, but it put Native rights on the national agenda in a way few events had before.
207:50
The question of the Black Hills, meanwhile, moved into the courts. For decades, the Lakota and the other nations of the Osseti Sakowin had argued that the law of 1877 taking the Black Hills violated the Fort Laramie Treaty of 1868.
208:04
In 1980, the case reached the Supreme Court of the United States. In a decision called United States v. Sioux Nation of Indians, the court agreed that the Black Hills had been taken illegally and it awarded the Sioux Nation's compensation the value of the land in 1877 plus interest, a total of around $106 million at the time.
208:24
The Sioux nations refused the money. Their position was simple. The Black Hills were not for sale, and accepting payment would mean accepting that the sale had been legitimate. They wanted the land, not the money. So the funds were placed in an account managed by the government, where they have continued to earn interest ever since. Today, the total has grown to well over a billion dollars. It is one of the largest sums of money in the world that nobody is willing to accept. Despite the deep poverty on some Lakota reservations, the refusal remains firm, a powerful statement that some things cannot be bought.
208:57
Adding to the tension, in the heart of the Black Hills stands Mount Rushmore, with the faces of four American presidents carved into a mountain that the Lakota knew as the Six Grandfathers.
209:08
In 2016, the Osseti Sakowin were once again at the centre of national attention.
209:13
A company planned to build the Dakota Access Pipeline, an oil pipeline that would pass under the Missouri River just upstream from the Standing Rock Reservation, the home of Sitting Bull's Hunkpapa descendants. The Standing Rock Sioux Tribe argued that the pipeline threatened their water supply and sacred sites and that they had not been properly consulted.
209:32
Protesters, who called themselves water protectors, gathered in camps near the river under the slogan Emni Wiconi, which means water is life.
209:41
Over the following months, thousands of people arrived from across the United States and around the world, including members of hundreds of native nations, environmental activists and military veterans. The pipeline was eventually completed and the legal battles over it continued for years, but Standing Rock became one of the largest gatherings of native nations in modern history.
210:02
And what of the Navajo, whose return from Bosque Redondo we followed with such relief? Today, the Navajo Nation covers about 71,000 square kilometers across Arizona, New Mexico and Utah, an area larger than 10 American states. It has its own government, with a president, a council and a court system, and its capital is at Window Rock in Arizona. Its enrolled citizens number close to 400,000, making it one of the largest native nations in the United States. The Navajo language is still spoken by a large number of people, more than any other native language in the country, and it is taught in schools, used on the radio, and even spoken in a dubbed version of Star Wars.
210:44
The people who once walked a Bosque Redondo on foot now run a nation larger than Ireland. Each of the nations in our story continues its own path. The Haudenosaunee Grand Council still meets at Onondaga, around a fire that its people say has been kept since the time of the peacemaker.
210:59
Lakota communities run language immersion schools to bring their language back to young children. The Comanche Nation, headquartered in Lawton, Oklahoma, holds an annual fair that brings together dancers, riders and families from across the country. The Apache nations, from Mescalero to San Carlos, continue to hold the sunrise ceremony for their young women. And the bison, brought to the brink of extinction in the 1880s, now number in the hundreds of thousands, with many native nations managing herds of their own on their own lands.
211:31
So that brings us to the end of our journey. We began with Comanche riders galloping toward the Gulf of Mexico, and we travelled back to the Ice Age, across Beringia, through the longhouses of the Haudenosaunee, along the trails of the Horse and the Gun, over the plains of Comanche area, and the black hills of the Lakota, through the canyons of the Navajo and the mountains of the Apache.
211:53
We followed these peoples through wars, exile and loss, and through extraordinary resilience. The most important lesson of the whole story may be the simplest one. These five nations did not disappear into the pages of a history book. They are still here, still defending their land, still speaking their languages, and still insisting on their right to tell their own history and their own words. Thank you for spending this time with me on such a long and remarkable journey. I hope it gave you something to think about as you drift off. Sleep well, sweet dreams, and good night.